{"id":20060413,"updated":"2026-02-10T20:52:00Z","additionalIndexing":"421;Aufgaben der Exekutive;Bericht;Motion;Beziehung Legislative-Exekutive","affairType":{"abbreviation":"Pa. Iv.","id":4,"name":"Parlamentarische Initiative"},"author":{"councillor":{"code":2512,"gender":"m","id":490,"name":"Lustenberger Ruedi","officialDenomination":"Lustenberger"},"faction":{"abbreviation":"Fraktion C","code":"M-E","id":3,"name":"Christlichdemokratische Fraktion"},"type":"author"},"deposit":{"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"date":"2006-03-24T00:00:00Z","legislativePeriod":47,"session":"4711"},"descriptors":[{"key":"L06K080301020105","name":"Motion","type":1},{"key":"L04K08030201","name":"Beziehung Legislative-Exekutive","type":1},{"key":"L04K08060201","name":"Aufgaben der Exekutive","type":1},{"key":"L03K020206","name":"Bericht","type":2}],"drafts":[{"consultation":{"resolutions":[{"category":{"id":3,"name":"Normal"},"committee":{"abbreviation":"SPK-NR","id":11,"name":"Staatspolitische Kommission NR","abbreviation1":"SPK-N","abbreviation2":"SPK","committeeNumber":11,"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"typeCode":1},"council":null,"date":"2006-09-15T00:00:00Z","text":"Folge geben (Erstrat)","type":16},{"category":{"id":3,"name":"Normal"},"committee":{"abbreviation":"SPK-SR","id":24,"name":"Staatspolitische Kommission SR","abbreviation1":"SPK-S","abbreviation2":"SPK","committeeNumber":24,"council":{"abbreviation":"SR","id":2,"name":"Ständerat","type":"S"},"typeCode":1},"council":null,"date":"2006-10-30T00:00:00Z","text":"Zustimmung","type":3}]},"federalCouncilProposal":{},"index":0,"links":[],"preConsultations":[{"committee":{"abbreviation":"SPK-SR","id":24,"name":"Staatspolitische Kommission SR","abbreviation1":"SPK-S","abbreviation2":"SPK","committeeNumber":24,"council":{"abbreviation":"SR","id":2,"name":"Ständerat","type":"S"},"typeCode":1},"date":"2006-03-24T00:00:00Z","registrations":[]},{"committee":{"abbreviation":"SPK-NR","id":11,"name":"Staatspolitische Kommission NR","abbreviation1":"SPK-N","abbreviation2":"SPK","committeeNumber":11,"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"typeCode":1},"date":"2006-03-24T00:00:00Z","registrations":[]}],"references":[{"date":"\/Date(1168556400000+0100)\/","publication":{"isOldFormat":false,"page":"1457","source":"BBl 2007 1457","type":{"id":1,"name":"Bundesblatt","shortName":"BBl"},"url":"http:\/\/www.admin.ch\/opc\/de\/federal-gazette\/2007\/1457.pdf","year":"2007"},"type":{"id":6,"name":"Bericht"}},{"date":"\/Date(1172617200000+0100)\/","publication":{"isOldFormat":false,"page":"2149","source":"BBl 2007 2149","type":{"id":1,"name":"Bundesblatt","shortName":"BBl"},"url":"http:\/\/www.admin.ch\/opc\/de\/federal-gazette\/2007\/2149.pdf","year":"2007"},"type":{"id":2,"name":"Stellungnahme des Bundesrates"}}],"relatedDepartments":[],"states":[{"date":"\/Date(1143154800000+0100)\/","id":24,"name":"Im Rat noch nicht behandelt"},{"date":"\/Date(1162162800000+0100)\/","id":1,"name":"Folge gegeben"},{"date":"\/Date(1180908000000+0200)\/","id":2,"name":"Behandelt vom Nationalrat"},{"date":"\/Date(1189980000000+0200)\/","id":4,"name":"Von beiden Räten behandelt"},{"date":"\/Date(1191535200000+0200)\/","id":229,"name":"Erledigt"}],"texts":[]},{"consultation":{"resolutions":[{"category":{"id":3,"name":"Normal"},"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"date":"2007-06-04T00:00:00Z","text":"Beschluss nach Entwurf der Kommission","type":0},{"category":{"id":3,"name":"Normal"},"council":{"abbreviation":"SR","id":2,"name":"Ständerat","type":"S"},"date":"2007-09-17T00:00:00Z","text":"Zustimmung","type":3},{"category":{"id":3,"name":"Normal"},"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"date":"2007-10-05T00:00:00Z","text":"Annahme in der Schlussabstimmung","type":36},{"category":{"id":3,"name":"Normal"},"council":{"abbreviation":"SR","id":2,"name":"Ständerat","type":"S"},"date":"2007-10-05T00:00:00Z","text":"Annahme in der Schlussabstimmung","type":36}]},"federalCouncilProposal":{},"index":1,"links":[],"preConsultations":[{"committee":{"abbreviation":"SPK-SR","id":24,"name":"Staatspolitische Kommission SR","abbreviation1":"SPK-S","abbreviation2":"SPK","committeeNumber":24,"council":{"abbreviation":"SR","id":2,"name":"Ständerat","type":"S"},"typeCode":1},"date":"2006-03-24T00:00:00Z","registrations":[{"correspondents":[{"council":{"abbreviation":"SR","id":2,"name":"Ständerat","type":"S"},"councillor":{"code":2267,"gender":"f","id":107,"name":"Heberlein Trix","officialDenomination":"Heberlein"},"faction":{"abbreviation":"Fraktion RL","code":"RL","id":1,"name":"Freisinnig-demokratische Fraktion"},"language":"de"}],"sessionId":"4718"}],"treatmentCategory":"IV"},{"committee":{"abbreviation":"SPK-NR","id":11,"name":"Staatspolitische Kommission NR","abbreviation1":"SPK-N","abbreviation2":"SPK","committeeNumber":11,"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"typeCode":1},"date":"2006-03-24T00:00:00Z","registrations":[{"correspondents":[{"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"councillor":{"code":2660,"gender":"f","id":1346,"name":"Moret Isabelle","officialDenomination":"Moret Isabelle"},"language":"fr"},{"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"councillor":{"code":2601,"gender":"f","id":1156,"name":"Heim Bea","officialDenomination":"Heim"},"faction":{"abbreviation":"Fraktion S","code":"S","id":2,"name":"Sozialdemokratische Fraktion"},"language":"de"}],"sessionId":"4716"}],"treatmentCategory":"IV"}],"references":[{"date":"\/Date(1143154800000+0100)\/","publication":{"isOldFormat":false,"type":{"id":1,"name":"Bundesblatt","shortName":"BBl"}},"title":"Bundesgesetz über die Bundesversammlung (Parlamentsgesetz, ParlG) (Verbindliche Wirkung der Motion)","type":{"id":1,"name":"Beratungsgegenstand \/ Entwurf"}},{"date":"\/Date(1192485600000+0200)\/","publication":{"isOldFormat":false,"page":"6949","source":"BBl 2007 6949","type":{"id":1,"name":"Bundesblatt","shortName":"BBl"},"url":"http:\/\/www.admin.ch\/opc\/de\/federal-gazette\/2007\/6949.pdf","year":"2007"},"referendumDeadline":"2008-01-24T00:00:00Z","type":{"id":3,"name":"Schlussabstimmungstext"}},{"date":"\/Date(1211234400000+0200)\/","publication":{"isOldFormat":false,"page":"2113","source":"AS 2008 2113","type":{"id":2,"name":"Amtliche Sammlung","shortName":"AS"},"url":"http:\/\/www.admin.ch\/opc\/de\/official-compilation\/2008\/2113.pdf","year":"2008"},"type":{"id":5,"name":"Amtliche Sammlung"}}],"relatedDepartments":[],"states":[{"date":"\/Date(1143154800000+0100)\/","id":24,"name":"Im Rat noch nicht behandelt"},{"date":"\/Date(1162162800000+0100)\/","id":1,"name":"Folge gegeben"},{"date":"\/Date(1180908000000+0200)\/","id":2,"name":"Behandelt vom Nationalrat"},{"date":"\/Date(1189980000000+0200)\/","id":4,"name":"Von beiden Räten behandelt"},{"date":"\/Date(1191535200000+0200)\/","id":229,"name":"Erledigt"}],"texts":[{"type":{"id":2,"name":"Titel der Vorlage"},"value":"Bundesgesetz über die Bundesversammlung (Parlamentsgesetz, ParlG) (Verbindliche Wirkung der Motion)"}]}],"language":"de","priorityCouncils":[{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N","priority":1}],"relatedAffairs":[],"roles":[{"councillor":{"code":2622,"gender":"m","id":1145,"name":"Perrin Yvan","officialDenomination":"Perrin"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2647,"gender":"m","id":1267,"name":"Stöckli Hans","officialDenomination":"Stöckli"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2564,"gender":"m","id":797,"name":"Donzé Walter","officialDenomination":"Donzé"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2654,"gender":"m","id":1318,"name":"Schelbert Louis","officialDenomination":"Schelbert"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2618,"gender":"m","id":1111,"name":"Müri Felix","officialDenomination":"Müri"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2470,"gender":"f","id":435,"name":"Meyer-Kaelin Thérèse","officialDenomination":"Meyer Thérèse"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2604,"gender":"f","id":1121,"name":"Hutter-Hutter Jasmin","officialDenomination":"Hutter Jasmin"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2571,"gender":"m","id":817,"name":"Imfeld Adriano","officialDenomination":"Imfeld Adriano"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2296,"gender":"m","id":97,"name":"Gross Andreas","officialDenomination":"Gross Andreas"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2375,"gender":"m","id":311,"name":"Christen Yves","officialDenomination":"Christen Yves"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2502,"gender":"m","id":478,"name":"Joder Rudolf","officialDenomination":"Joder"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2461,"gender":"m","id":419,"name":"Beck Serge","officialDenomination":"Beck Serge"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2627,"gender":"m","id":1119,"name":"Rime Jean-François","officialDenomination":"Rime"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2382,"gender":"m","id":318,"name":"Engelberger Edi","officialDenomination":"Engelberger"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2616,"gender":"m","id":1141,"name":"Müller Philipp","officialDenomination":"Müller Philipp"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2579,"gender":"m","id":1065,"name":"Leuenberger Ueli","officialDenomination":"Leuenberger-Genève"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2508,"gender":"m","id":484,"name":"Laubacher Otto","officialDenomination":"Laubacher"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2347,"gender":"m","id":264,"name":"Weyeneth Hermann","officialDenomination":"Weyeneth"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2623,"gender":"m","id":1109,"name":"Pfister Gerhard","officialDenomination":"Pfister Gerhard"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2306,"gender":"m","id":131,"name":"Leu Josef","officialDenomination":"Leu Josef"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2584,"gender":"m","id":1135,"name":"Amstutz Adrian","officialDenomination":"Amstutz"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2544,"gender":"f","id":522,"name":"Wyss Ursula","officialDenomination":"Wyss Ursula"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2572,"gender":"m","id":820,"name":"Schibli Ernst","officialDenomination":"Schibli"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2594,"gender":"m","id":1122,"name":"Fluri Kurt","officialDenomination":"Fluri"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2512,"gender":"m","id":490,"name":"Lustenberger Ruedi","officialDenomination":"Lustenberger"},"faction":{"abbreviation":"Fraktion C","code":"M-E","id":3,"name":"Christlichdemokratische Fraktion"},"type":"author"}],"sequentialNumber":312,"shortId":"06.413","state":{"id":229,"name":"Erledigt","doneKey":"0","newKey":0},"texts":[{"type":{"id":6,"name":"Begründung"},"value":"<p>Anlass dieser parlamentarischen Initiative gibt der Beschluss des Bundesrates vom 21. Dezember 2005, die Motion 04.3433, \"Presseförderung mittels Beteiligung an den Verteilkosten\", nicht zu erfüllen. Der Bundesrat hat durch die Medien mitgeteilt, dass verschiedene Varianten zur Erfüllung der Motion geprüft wurden. Ein entsprechender Bericht liegt aber nicht vor. Der Bundesrat hat es auch unterlassen, im Rahmen des jährlichen Berichtes über Motionen und Postulate der gesetzgebenden Räte zum Jahr 2005 vom 30. März 2006 die Abschreibung zu beantragen. Die zuständigen Kommissionen bzw. das Parlament kennen weder die Gründe der bundesrätlichen Auftragsverweigerung noch hatten sie Gelegenheit, innert nützlicher Frist dazu Stellung zu nehmen. Den Kommissionen blieb in dieser Situation als einziges Instrument die parlamentarische Initiative. <\/p><p>Gemäss Artikel 122 Absatz 2 ParlG kann der Bundesrat die Abschreibung einer Motion nicht nur nach ihrer Erfüllung, sondern auch dann beantragen, wenn der Auftrag \"nicht aufrechterhalten werden soll\". Dieses Vorgehen kann in Ausnahmefällen gerechtfertigt sein. Das Parlamentsgesetz verlangt zwar bereits heute eine entsprechende Begründung; es macht aber keine näheren Angaben über die Modalitäten. Es entspricht hingegen nicht dem klaren Rollenverständnis zwischen Exekutive und Gesetzgeber, wenn der Bundesrat die Begründung im Rahmen der jährlichen Berichte über Motionen und Postulate nur in sehr knapper Form liefert. <\/p><p>Schliesslich handelt es sich bei der Motion um ein gewollt starkes Auftragsinstrument des Gesetzgebers an die Adresse der ausführenden Behörde. Es soll deshalb nicht mehr vorkommen, dass die Rechtswirkung der Motion vom Bundesrat in einer Art und Weise verwässert wird, wie sie der Gesetzgeber ursprünglich nicht gewollt hat.<\/p>"},{"type":{"id":5,"name":"Eingereichter Text"},"value":"<p>Gestützt auf Artikel 160 Absatz 1 der Bundesverfassung und auf Artikel 107 des Parlamentsgesetzes reiche ich folgende parlamentarische Initiative ein:<\/p><p>Das Parlamentsgesetz ist in der Weise zu ändern, dass die Verbindlichkeit einer von beiden Räten überwiesenen Motion verstärkt werden soll. Falls der Bundesrat den Auftrag ausnahmsweise nicht oder nur teilweise erfüllen will, soll er den entsprechenden Abschreibungsantrag mit einem gesonderten Bericht an die Räte begründen. Wird der Abschreibungsantrag von beiden Kammern abgelehnt, muss der Bundesrat den Auftrag umgehend erfüllen.<\/p>"},{"type":{"id":1,"name":"Titel des Geschäftes"},"value":"Verbindliche Wirkung der Motion"}],"title":"Verbindliche Wirkung der Motion"}