{"id":20133461,"updated":"2025-06-24T23:46:21Z","additionalIndexing":"2846;Evaluation;Beziehung Bund-Kanton;Sachplan;Vollzug von Beschlüssen;Gesetzesevaluation","affairType":{"abbreviation":"Po.","id":6,"name":"Postulat"},"author":{"councillor":{"code":2761,"gender":"m","id":4054,"name":"Vitali Albert","officialDenomination":"Vitali"},"faction":{"abbreviation":"Fraktion RL","code":"RL","id":1,"name":"FDP-Liberale Fraktion"},"type":"author"},"deposit":{"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"date":"2013-06-18T00:00:00Z","legislativePeriod":49,"session":"4909"},"descriptors":[{"key":"L04K01020412","name":"Sachplan","type":1},{"key":"L04K08020302","name":"Evaluation","type":1},{"key":"L07K08070102010101","name":"Beziehung Bund-Kanton","type":1},{"key":"L03K080703","name":"Vollzug von Beschlüssen","type":1},{"key":"L04K08070301","name":"Gesetzesevaluation","type":1}],"drafts":[{"consultation":{"resolutions":[{"category":{"id":3,"name":"Normal"},"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"date":"2013-09-27T00:00:00Z","text":"Annahme","type":20},{"category":{"id":3,"name":"Normal"},"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"date":"2018-06-05T00:00:00Z","text":"Abschreibung","type":15},{"category":{"id":3,"name":"Normal"},"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"date":"2018-06-05T00:00:00Z","text":"Im Zusammenhang mit der Beratung des Geschäfts 18.006.","type":0}]},"federalCouncilProposal":{"code":"+","date":"2013-08-21T00:00:00Z","text":"Der Bundesrat beantragt die Annahme des Postulates."},"index":0,"links":[],"preConsultations":[],"references":[],"relatedDepartments":[{"abbreviation":"UVEK","id":9,"name":"Departement für Umwelt, Verkehr, Energie und Kommunikation","leading":true}],"states":[{"date":"\/Date(1371506400000+0200)\/","id":24,"name":"Im Rat noch nicht behandelt"},{"date":"\/Date(1380232800000+0200)\/","id":26,"name":"Angenommen"},{"date":"\/Date(1528149600000+0200)\/","id":229,"name":"Erledigt"}],"texts":[]}],"handling":{"date":"2013-09-27T00:00:00Z","legislativePeriod":49,"session":"4910"},"language":"de","priorityCouncils":[{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N","priority":1}],"relatedAffairs":[],"roles":[{"councillor":{"code":2614,"gender":"f","id":1139,"name":"Markwalder Christa","officialDenomination":"Markwalder"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2602,"gender":"f","id":1103,"name":"Huber Gabi","officialDenomination":"Huber"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2631,"gender":"m","id":1159,"name":"Schwander Pirmin","officialDenomination":"Schwander"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2594,"gender":"m","id":1122,"name":"Fluri Kurt","officialDenomination":"Fluri"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2711,"gender":"m","id":3908,"name":"von Graffenried Alec","officialDenomination":"von Graffenried"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2715,"gender":"m","id":3912,"name":"Wasserfallen Christian","officialDenomination":"Wasserfallen Christian"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2743,"gender":"f","id":4030,"name":"Birrer-Heimo Prisca","officialDenomination":"Birrer-Heimo"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2617,"gender":"m","id":1137,"name":"Müller Walter","officialDenomination":"Müller Walter"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2605,"gender":"m","id":1126,"name":"Hutter Markus","officialDenomination":"Hutter Markus"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2678,"gender":"f","id":3875,"name":"Eichenberger-Walther Corina","officialDenomination":"Eichenberger"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2619,"gender":"m","id":1153,"name":"Noser Ruedi","officialDenomination":"Noser"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2654,"gender":"m","id":1318,"name":"Schelbert Louis","officialDenomination":"Schelbert"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2661,"gender":"m","id":1345,"name":"Müller Thomas","officialDenomination":"Müller Thomas"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2670,"gender":"m","id":3867,"name":"Aebi Andreas","officialDenomination":"Aebi Andreas"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2612,"gender":"m","id":1113,"name":"Leutenegger Filippo","officialDenomination":"Leutenegger Filippo"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2679,"gender":"f","id":3876,"name":"Estermann Yvette","officialDenomination":"Estermann"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2748,"gender":"f","id":4040,"name":"Schneider-Schneiter Elisabeth","officialDenomination":"Schneider-Schneiter"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2685,"gender":"m","id":3882,"name":"Girod Bastien","officialDenomination":"Girod"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2680,"gender":"f","id":3877,"name":"Fiala Doris","officialDenomination":"Fiala"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2618,"gender":"m","id":1111,"name":"Müri Felix","officialDenomination":"Müri"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2691,"gender":"m","id":3888,"name":"Hiltpold Hugues","officialDenomination":"Hiltpold"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2682,"gender":"m","id":3879,"name":"Français Olivier","officialDenomination":"Français"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2675,"gender":"m","id":3872,"name":"Bourgeois Jacques","officialDenomination":"Bourgeois"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2660,"gender":"f","id":1346,"name":"Moret Isabelle","officialDenomination":"Moret Isabelle"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2725,"gender":"m","id":3922,"name":"Favre Laurent","officialDenomination":"Favre Laurent"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2664,"gender":"m","id":3828,"name":"Cassis Ignazio","officialDenomination":"Cassis"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2409,"gender":"m","id":345,"name":"Pelli Fulvio","officialDenomination":"Pelli"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2754,"gender":"m","id":4052,"name":"Ritter Markus","officialDenomination":"Ritter"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2758,"gender":"m","id":4053,"name":"Aeschi Thomas","officialDenomination":"Aeschi"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2765,"gender":"m","id":4059,"name":"Flach Beat","officialDenomination":"Flach"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2766,"gender":"f","id":4060,"name":"Schneeberger Daniela","officialDenomination":"Schneeberger"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2764,"gender":"m","id":4071,"name":"Gasche Urs","officialDenomination":"Gasche"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2770,"gender":"m","id":4070,"name":"Candinas Martin","officialDenomination":"Candinas Martin"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2775,"gender":"m","id":4075,"name":"Caroni Andrea","officialDenomination":"Caroni"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2789,"gender":"m","id":4077,"name":"Feller Olivier","officialDenomination":"Feller"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2784,"gender":"m","id":4084,"name":"Pezzatti Bruno","officialDenomination":"Pezzatti"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2794,"gender":"m","id":4089,"name":"Fischer Roland","officialDenomination":"Fischer Roland"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2799,"gender":"m","id":4094,"name":"Hess Lorenz","officialDenomination":"Hess Lorenz"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3001,"gender":"m","id":4096,"name":"Gmür Alois","officialDenomination":"Gmür Alois"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3013,"gender":"m","id":4098,"name":"Keller Peter","officialDenomination":"Keller Peter"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3002,"gender":"m","id":4103,"name":"Hausammann Markus","officialDenomination":"Hausammann"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3006,"gender":"m","id":4111,"name":"Ribaux Alain","officialDenomination":"Ribaux"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3023,"gender":"f","id":4116,"name":"Gössi Petra","officialDenomination":"Gössi"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3031,"gender":"m","id":4126,"name":"Stolz Daniel","officialDenomination":"Stolz"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2761,"gender":"m","id":4054,"name":"Vitali Albert","officialDenomination":"Vitali"},"faction":{"abbreviation":"Fraktion RL","code":"RL","id":1,"name":"FDP-Liberale Fraktion"},"type":"author"}],"shortId":"13.3461","state":{"id":229,"name":"Erledigt","doneKey":"0","newKey":0},"texts":[{"type":{"id":6,"name":"Begründung"},"value":"<p>Der Bund hat mit dem Raumplanungsgesetz ein gutes Planungsinstrument. Der Bund ist jedoch mit der Sachplanung gegenüber den gesetzlichen Anforderungen im Verzug. Die Bundesplanung ist mehr als 30 Jahre nach Inkrafttreten des Raumplanungsgesetzes immer noch nicht vollständig. Anstatt in den Sachplänen aufzuzeigen, wie er seine raumwirksamen Aufgaben untereinander und gegenüber den Kantonen und Gemeinden abstimmt, beschäftigt sich der Bund noch immer mit Grundsatzfragen, wie z. B. jene nach der Planungspflicht und Sachplanrelevanz einzelner Vorhaben, nach der rechtlichen Tragweite von Sachplaneinträgen oder der Einbindung der Kantone und anderer raumplanerischer Akteure in die Sachplanerarbeitung. Die planerischen Rückstände oder Versäumnisse erschweren die Koordination und die Arbeit der Kantone, Städte und Gemeinden. Sie haben 1989 sogar zu einer Rüge durch das Bundesgericht geführt (BGE 115 Ib 131). Die Raumplanungsverordnung vom 22. Oktober 1997 verlangt, dass die für Raumplanung und Regionalpolitik zuständigen Fachstellen des Bundes in Zusammenarbeit mit der Raumordnungskonferenz des Bundes, der sämtliche Verwaltungseinheiten des Bundes mit raumplanungsrelevanten Aufgaben angehören, für die Evaluation der raumordnungspolitischen Massnahmen des Bundes sowie der Bestrebungen im Bereich der Koordination sorgen. Sie müssen dem Bundesrat zuhanden der eidgenössischen Räte einmal pro Legislaturperiode Bericht über die Ergebnisse dieser Evaluation erstatten (Art. 9). Dieser Verpflichtung kommt der Bund schon lange nicht mehr nach. Mit der Volksabstimmung zum neuen Raumplanungsgesetz hat das Volk gezeigt, dass es einen besseren Vollzug der Raumplanung will. Dies gilt auch für den Bund. Der Handlungsbedarf ist also umso mehr gegeben. Die Schwachstellen der heutigen Bundesplanung sind in einem Bericht aufzuzeigen, und es sind Wege zu formulieren, wie die Situation verbessert werden kann. Um Objektivität zu gewährleisten, wäre es prüfenswert, den Bericht von externer Seite erstellen zu lassen.<\/p>"},{"type":{"id":14,"name":"Antwort BR \/ Büro"},"value":"Der Bundesrat beantragt die Annahme des Postulates."},{"type":{"id":5,"name":"Eingereichter Text"},"value":"<p>Der Bundesrat wird beauftragt, einen Bericht über die Evaluation der Sachplanung des Bundes sowie der Bestrebungen im Bereich der Koordination vorzulegen.<\/p>"},{"type":{"id":1,"name":"Titel des Geschäftes"},"value":"Evaluation der Sachplanung des Bundes"}],"title":"Evaluation der Sachplanung des Bundes"}