{"id":20164103,"updated":"2023-07-28T04:44:00Z","additionalIndexing":"2811;08;09","affairType":{"abbreviation":"Mo.","id":5,"name":"Motion"},"author":{"councillor":{"code":2772,"gender":"m","id":4067,"name":"Brand Heinz","officialDenomination":"Brand"},"faction":{"abbreviation":"Fraktion V","code":"V","id":4,"name":"Fraktion der Schweizerischen Volkspartei"},"type":"author"},"deposit":{"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"date":"2016-12-16T00:00:00Z","legislativePeriod":50,"session":"5006"},"descriptors":[],"drafts":[{"consultation":{"resolutions":[{"category":{"id":3,"name":"Normal"},"council":{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N"},"date":"2018-02-28T00:00:00Z","text":"Ablehnung","type":22}]},"federalCouncilProposal":{"code":"-","date":"2017-03-03T00:00:00Z","text":"Der Bundesrat beantragt die Ablehnung der Motion."},"index":0,"links":[],"preConsultations":[],"references":[],"relatedDepartments":[{"abbreviation":"EFD","id":7,"name":"Finanzdepartement","leading":true}],"states":[{"date":"\/Date(1481842800000+0100)\/","id":24,"name":"Im Rat noch nicht behandelt"},{"date":"\/Date(1519772400000+0100)\/","id":229,"name":"Erledigt"}],"texts":[]}],"language":"de","priorityCouncils":[{"abbreviation":"NR","id":1,"name":"Nationalrat","type":"N","priority":1}],"relatedAffairs":[],"roles":[{"councillor":{"code":2372,"gender":"m","id":307,"name":"Brunner Toni","officialDenomination":"Brunner Toni"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2701,"gender":"m","id":3898,"name":"Nidegger Yves","officialDenomination":"Nidegger"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2631,"gender":"m","id":1159,"name":"Schwander Pirmin","officialDenomination":"Schwander"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2693,"gender":"m","id":3890,"name":"Hurter Thomas","officialDenomination":"Hurter Thomas"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2584,"gender":"m","id":1135,"name":"Amstutz Adrian","officialDenomination":"Amstutz"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2292,"gender":"m","id":91,"name":"Giezendanner Ulrich","officialDenomination":"Giezendanner"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2617,"gender":"m","id":1137,"name":"Müller Walter","officialDenomination":"Müller Walter"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2670,"gender":"m","id":3867,"name":"Aebi Andreas","officialDenomination":"Aebi Andreas"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2638,"gender":"m","id":1142,"name":"Wobmann Walter","officialDenomination":"Wobmann"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2752,"gender":"m","id":4046,"name":"Quadri Lorenzo","officialDenomination":"Quadri"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2757,"gender":"m","id":4051,"name":"de Courten Thomas","officialDenomination":"de Courten"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2758,"gender":"m","id":4053,"name":"Aeschi Thomas","officialDenomination":"Aeschi"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2776,"gender":"m","id":4072,"name":"Regazzi Fabio","officialDenomination":"Regazzi"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2773,"gender":"f","id":4073,"name":"Pantani Roberta","officialDenomination":"Pantani"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2781,"gender":"f","id":4065,"name":"Umbricht Pieren Nadja","officialDenomination":"Umbricht Pieren"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3013,"gender":"m","id":4098,"name":"Keller Peter","officialDenomination":"Keller Peter"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3002,"gender":"m","id":4103,"name":"Hausammann Markus","officialDenomination":"Hausammann"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3010,"gender":"m","id":4100,"name":"Rösti Albert","officialDenomination":"Rösti"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3030,"gender":"m","id":4125,"name":"Rutz Gregor","officialDenomination":"Rutz Gregor"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3021,"gender":"m","id":4114,"name":"Knecht Hansjörg","officialDenomination":"Knecht"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3039,"gender":"m","id":4137,"name":"Golay Roger","officialDenomination":"Golay Roger"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3033,"gender":"f","id":4129,"name":"Herzog Verena","officialDenomination":"Herzog Verena"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3037,"gender":"m","id":4135,"name":"Clottu Raymond","officialDenomination":"Clottu"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3046,"gender":"m","id":4144,"name":"Matter Thomas","officialDenomination":"Matter Thomas"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2740,"gender":"m","id":4025,"name":"Büchel Roland Rino","officialDenomination":"Büchel Roland"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2683,"gender":"f","id":3880,"name":"Geissbühler Andrea Martina","officialDenomination":"Geissbühler"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2705,"gender":"f","id":3902,"name":"Rickli Natalie","officialDenomination":"Rickli Natalie"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2618,"gender":"m","id":1111,"name":"Müri Felix","officialDenomination":"Müri"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3055,"gender":"m","id":4154,"name":"Addor Jean-Luc","officialDenomination":"Addor"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3057,"gender":"m","id":4155,"name":"Arnold Beat","officialDenomination":"Arnold"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3062,"gender":"m","id":4156,"name":"Buffat Michaël","officialDenomination":"Buffat"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3063,"gender":"m","id":4157,"name":"Bühler Manfred","officialDenomination":"Bühler"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3064,"gender":"m","id":4158,"name":"Burgherr Thomas","officialDenomination":"Burgherr"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3067,"gender":"m","id":4159,"name":"Chiesa Marco","officialDenomination":"Chiesa"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3069,"gender":"m","id":4160,"name":"Dettling Marcel","officialDenomination":"Dettling"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3074,"gender":"m","id":4161,"name":"Glarner Andreas","officialDenomination":"Glarner"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3076,"gender":"m","id":4162,"name":"Grüter Franz","officialDenomination":"Grüter"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3080,"gender":"m","id":4164,"name":"Imark Christian","officialDenomination":"Imark"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3085,"gender":"f","id":4167,"name":"Martullo-Blocher Magdalena","officialDenomination":"Martullo"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3089,"gender":"m","id":4168,"name":"Nicolet Jacques","officialDenomination":"Nicolet"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3090,"gender":"m","id":4169,"name":"Page Pierre-André","officialDenomination":"Page"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3091,"gender":"m","id":4170,"name":"Ruppen Franz","officialDenomination":"Ruppen"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3092,"gender":"m","id":4172,"name":"Salzmann Werner","officialDenomination":"Salzmann"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3096,"gender":"f","id":4174,"name":"Steinemann Barbara","officialDenomination":"Steinemann"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3097,"gender":"m","id":4175,"name":"Tuena Mauro","officialDenomination":"Tuena"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3101,"gender":"m","id":4178,"name":"Zanetti Claudio","officialDenomination":"Zanetti Claudio"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3102,"gender":"m","id":4179,"name":"Zuberbühler David","officialDenomination":"Zuberbühler"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":3065,"gender":"m","id":4189,"name":"Burkart Thierry","officialDenomination":"Burkart"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2686,"gender":"f","id":3883,"name":"Glauser-Zufferey Alice","officialDenomination":"Glauser"},"type":"cosign"},{"councillor":{"code":2772,"gender":"m","id":4067,"name":"Brand Heinz","officialDenomination":"Brand"},"faction":{"abbreviation":"Fraktion V","code":"V","id":4,"name":"Fraktion der Schweizerischen Volkspartei"},"type":"author"}],"shortId":"16.4103","state":{"id":229,"name":"Erledigt","doneKey":"0","newKey":0},"texts":[{"type":{"id":6,"name":"Begründung"},"value":"<p>Der Migrationsdruck in Europa wird sich in den nächsten Jahren wohl eher verstärken als abnehmen. Bereits heute schützen sich deshalb zahlreiche Staaten mit verschiedenen baulichen Massnahmen zur besseren Kontrolle der Einreiseströme, namentlich auch zur Verhinderung illegaler Einreisen. Deutschland, Österreich, Ungarn, Spanien mögen als Beispiele hierfür dienen, welche zahlreiche Einrichtungen zur Abwehr von illegalen Einreisen erstellt haben. Der Bau von Grenzschutzanlagen dürfte in baulicher, aber auch in rechtlicher Hinsicht ein schwieriges Unterfangen sein. Dies gilt namentlich in überbauten Gebieten wie Städten oder im Bereich von stark frequentierten Verkehrsachsen. Es ist deshalb ein Gebot vorausschauenden Handelns, rechtzeitig die erforderlichen Rechtsgrundlagen zum Bau solcher Grenzschutzanlagen zu erlassen.<\/p>"},{"type":{"id":14,"name":"Antwort BR \/ Büro"},"value":"<p>Wie der Bundesrat in seiner Antwort auf die Interpellation Brand 16.3820 festgehalten hat, spricht nicht in erster Linie das Fehlen einer gesetzlichen Grundlage gegen die Erstellung von Grenzbefestigungsanlagen, sondern die Frage nach der praktischen Durchführbarkeit der Massnahme sowie ihr beschränkter Nutzen. Weiter hat der Bundesrat in obengenannter Antwort auch darauf hingewiesen, dass er im Rahmen seiner bestehenden verfassungsmässigen Kompetenzen befristete bauliche Massnahmen im Grenzgebiet treffen kann, sollte es die Situation erfordern.<\/p><p>Ein Grenzzaun wäre ein sehr kostspieliges und kaum verhältnismässiges Mittel, um die illegale Migration einzudämmen. Zudem gilt es, mögliche Konflikte mit dem Schengener Grenzkodex zu vermeiden.<\/p><p>Der überwiegende Teil der Migranten, die das Grenzwachtkorps an der Südgrenze anhält, reist mit dem Zug ein. So werden rund 85 Prozent aller illegalen Aufenthalter im Tessin auf dem Bahnhof Chiasso aufgegriffen. Selbst in den Monaten, in denen der grösste Migrationsdruck herrschte, machten die Aufgriffe an der grünen Grenze dagegen lediglich 6,4 Prozent aus.<\/p><p>Zusammenfassend ist der Bundesrat der Meinung, dass angesichts der geringen Zahlen an illegalen Grenzübertritten an der grünen Grenze der Erlass von Rechtsgrundlagen zum Bau von Grenzbefestigungsanlagen zurzeit nicht gerechtfertigt wäre.<\/p>  Der Bundesrat beantragt die Ablehnung der Motion."},{"type":{"id":5,"name":"Eingereichter Text"},"value":"<p>Der Bundesrat wird beauftragt, ohne Verzug Rechtsgrundlagen zum Bau von Grenzbefestigungsanlagen zu erlassen, wo sich solche als zweckmässig und notwendig erweisen. In der Antwort auf die Interpellation 16.3820 hat der Bundesrat unmissverständlich festgehalten, dass derzeit keine klaren Rechtsgrundlagen zum Bau von Grenzschutzanlagen bestehen und im Bedarfsfall solche nur aufgrund von notrechtlichen Kompetenzen erstellt werden können.<\/p>"},{"type":{"id":1,"name":"Titel des Geschäftes"},"value":"Schaffung der Rechtsgrundlagen zum Bau von Grenzbefestigungsanlagen"}],"title":"Schaffung der Rechtsgrundlagen zum Bau von Grenzbefestigungsanlagen"}