200204732022-12-31T03:04:52Z57861078543Yes223FabioAbate25651078434EH153AndreasAebi26701078522Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731078502Yes50EviAllemann25831078518No25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711078552Yes30ViolaAmherd26461078587No217AdrianAmstutz25841078464Yes24JosianeAubert26681078596No286CasparBaader24541078550Yes65ElviraBader24741078454EH154DominiqueBaettig26731078455Yes26MarliesBänziger26721078506Yes164LucBarthassat26491078507No341J. AlexanderBaumann23691078486Yes206MartinBäumle25851078437Yes342DidierBerberat23701078498Yes77MariaBernasconi24361078515No282ElmarBigger24761078438No207AttilioBignasca25861078592No382MaxBinder22701078514Yes155PirminBischof26741078553NT383Roland F.Borer22721078523No384ToniBortoluzzi22741078503EH156JacquesBourgeois26751078427NT440DanielBrélaz20231078400Yes48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731078594No343ToniBrunner23721078583No51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871078405Yes208JakobBüchler25881078545No283AndréBugnon24771078496Yes23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661078499EH162IgnazioCassis26641078562Yes210SepCathomas25901078489EH157TarzisiusCaviezel26771078576Yes272MauriceChevrier24791078462Yes455MaxChopard-Acklin27341078524Yes211AndréDaguet25911078582Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921078546Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931078520Yes222WalterDonzé25641078452No276Jean HenriDunant24841078510Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761078461EH16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781078403No327EdiEngelberger23821078588No17YvetteEstermann26791078572Yes79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481078581NT267CharlesFavre24871078410EH125LaurentFavre27251078547No328HansFehr23831078566Yes268Hans-JürgFehr24881078532Yes81JacquelineFehr24551078564Yes269MarioFehr24891078493EH18DorisFiala26801078456No19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811078459NT202KurtFluri25941078436No330PeterFöhn23851078501Yes146OlivierFrançais26821078513Yes203OskarFreysinger25951078478Yes40ThereseFrösch25961078487No165LieniFüglistaller26511078471Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541078526Yes41ChantalGalladé25971078557Yes20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831078402No204Jean-RenéGermanier25981078563No370UlrichGiezendanner22921078480NT21YvonneGilli26841078417Yes147BastienGirod26851078560Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571078519Yes10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861078442Yes261WalterGlur24941078540Yes100ChristineGoll22941078430No148Jean-PierreGraber26871078451Yes46MayaGraf25691078407Yes32EdithGraf-Litscher26521078481Yes149Jean-PierreGrin26881078490Yes371AndreasGross22961078467Yes150HansGrunder26891078565NT422Hans RudolfGysin20771078584Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001078465Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961078538Yes372AndreaHämmerle22981078548Yes158UrsHany26591078469Yes263HansjörgHassler24971078475No151AlfredHeer26901078470Yes44BeaHeim26011078505EH140HuguesHiltpold26911078591Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931078415Yes141AntonioHodgers26921078573No45GabiHuber26021078593Yes49RuthHumbel25801078424No142ThomasHurter26931078529NT205MarkusHutter26051078511No35JasminHutter-Hutter26041078491Yes194OttoIneichen26061078477No256RudolfJoder25021078435Yes31FrancineJohn-Calame26501078447Yes143DanielJositsch26941078428NT257HansKaufmann25031078468Yes36MargretKiener Nellen26081078412No144HansKiller26951078571No37MarianneKleiner26091078509Yes318JosefKunz23991078449Yes11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961078463Yes456MartinLandolt27351078453Yes197JosefLang26111078474Yes216UeliLeuenberger25791078531No198FilippoLeutenegger26121078542Yes116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291078528Yes199ChristianLevrat26131078589NT250ArthurLoepfe25111078443Yes145RicardoLumengo26971078541EH134ChristianLüscher26981078597Yes251RuediLustenberger25121078497Yes135PeterMalama26991078533No38ChristaMarkwalder26141078466Yes9AdaMarra27261078580Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161078569No243WernerMessmer25181078578Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701078414No367ChristianMiesch23111078537NT22IsabelleMoret26601078483No244ChristophMörgeli25191078484Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001078419Yes188GeriMüller26151078527No189PhilippMüller26161078556NT159ThomasMüller26611078525No190WalterMüller26171078418No191FelixMüri26181078408NT246JacquesNeirynck25211078440NT136YvesNidegger27011078598Yes175RogerNordmann26481078535NT192RuediNoser26191078445Yes137EricNussbaumer27021078401No182GuyParmelin26211078500Yes247FabioPedrina25221078575No313FulvioPelli24091078479Yes183YvanPerrin26221078539No13SylviePerrinjaquet27031078554No184GerhardPfister26231078448No236TheophilPfister25231078431Yes447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321078570Yes415PaulRechsteiner21431078460Yes304RudolfRechsteiner24121078420No138LukasReimann27041078439Yes305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131078450No187AndréReymond26261078416No14NatalieRickli27051078441Yes139Jean-CharlesRielle27061078595Yes53KathyRiklin25251078555Yes176Jean-FrançoisRime26271078544Yes237MeinradoRobbiani25261078530Yes238StéphaneRossini25271078585No239ClaudeRuey25281078549No173HansRutschmann26441078421Yes166LouisSchelbert26541078446No349SimonSchenk23511078534Yes29SilviaSchenker26301078551No240MarcelScherer25291078517No213ErnstSchibli25721078458No307UlrichSchlüer24151078512Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071078508Yes128RobertoSchmidt27081078577NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301078432No177PirminSchwander26311078516Yes129PiusSegmüller27091078399P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331078494Yes178CarloSommaruga26321078561No232PeterSpuhler25351078521No233JürgStahl25361078422No361LuziStamm23231078492Yes152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691078472Yes174HansStöckli26471078504Yes82DorisStump24211078476Yes83FranziskaTeuscher24221078574Yes84AnitaThanei24231078579NT300GeorgesTheiler24241078433Yes7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101078567No235PierreTriponez25381078536Yes163AndyTschümperlin26651078425Yes126Christianvan Singer27271078426NT180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341078457Yes181DanielVischer26351078429Yes130Alecvon Graffenried27111078444No131Christophvon Rotz27121078485Yes132Erichvon Siebenthal27131078406Yes133EricVoruz27141078404No295ChristianWaber24491078473No226HansjörgWalter25411078590No227HansruediWandfluh25421078495No124ChristianWasserfallen27151078413Yes448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331078586Yes171RetoWehrli26371078482Yes127ThomasWeibel27281078488Yes294HansWidmer24461078409No172WalterWobmann26381078423Yes8BrigitWyss27161078568Yes56UrsulaWyss25441078558Yes168MarkusZemp26561078411Yes344JosefZisyadis23331078559No219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-19T16:47:04ZEntrer en matièreProposition de la minorité Rutschmann (ne pas entrer en matière)Proposition de la majorité (entrer en matière)2046Bundesgesetz über die Reduktion der CO2-Emissionen (CO2-Gesetz) (Anreize für energetisch wirksame Massnahmen im Gebäudebereich)Yes110No62EH10NT17P1Yes110No62EH10NT17ES0P157871078743Yes223FabioAbate25651078634No153AndreasAebi26701078722No281RuediAeschbacher24731078702No50EviAllemann25831078718No25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711078752Yes30ViolaAmherd26461078787Yes217AdrianAmstutz25841078664No24JosianeAubert26681078796No286CasparBaader24541078750No65ElviraBader24741078654No154DominiqueBaettig26731078655No26MarliesBänziger26721078706No164LucBarthassat26491078707NT341J. AlexanderBaumann23691078686No206MartinBäumle25851078637No342DidierBerberat23701078698No77MariaBernasconi24361078715No282ElmarBigger24761078638No207AttilioBignasca25861078792No382MaxBinder22701078714No155PirminBischof26741078753NT383Roland F.Borer22721078723NT384ToniBortoluzzi22741078703No156JacquesBourgeois26751078627NT440DanielBrélaz20231078600No48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731078794No343ToniBrunner23721078783Yes51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871078605No208JakobBüchler25881078745No283AndréBugnon24771078696No23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661078699Yes162IgnazioCassis26641078762No210SepCathomas25901078689Yes157TarzisiusCaviezel26771078776No272MauriceChevrier24791078662No455MaxChopard-Acklin27341078724No211AndréDaguet25911078782Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921078746No201Dominiquede Buman25931078720Yes222WalterDonzé25641078652NT276Jean HenriDunant24841078710Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761078661Yes16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781078603NT327EdiEngelberger23821078788Yes17YvetteEstermann26791078772No79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481078781NT267CharlesFavre24871078610No125LaurentFavre27251078747NT328HansFehr23831078766No268Hans-JürgFehr24881078732No81JacquelineFehr24551078764No269MarioFehr24891078693Yes18DorisFiala26801078656Yes19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811078659NT202KurtFluri25941078636No330PeterFöhn23851078701No146OlivierFrançais26821078713No203OskarFreysinger25951078678No40ThereseFrösch25961078687No165LieniFüglistaller26511078671No94Brigitta M.Gadient23541078726No41ChantalGalladé25971078757No20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831078602Yes204Jean-RenéGermanier25981078763No370UlrichGiezendanner22921078680NT21YvonneGilli26841078617No147BastienGirod26851078760No33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571078719No10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861078642NT261WalterGlur24941078740No100ChristineGoll22941078630NT148Jean-PierreGraber26871078651No46MayaGraf25691078607No32EdithGraf-Litscher26521078681NT149Jean-PierreGrin26881078690No371AndreasGross22961078667No150HansGrunder26891078765NT422Hans RudolfGysin20771078784Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001078665No58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961078738No372AndreaHämmerle22981078748No158UrsHany26591078669No263HansjörgHassler24971078675No151AlfredHeer26901078670No44BeaHeim26011078705No140HuguesHiltpold26911078791No325NorbertHochreutener23931078615No141AntonioHodgers26921078773Yes45GabiHuber26021078793No49RuthHumbel25801078624NT142ThomasHurter26931078729Yes205MarkusHutter26051078711NT35JasminHutter-Hutter26041078691No194OttoIneichen26061078677No256RudolfJoder25021078635No31FrancineJohn-Calame26501078647No143DanielJositsch26941078628NT257HansKaufmann25031078668No36MargretKiener Nellen26081078612No144HansKiller26951078771Yes37MarianneKleiner26091078709No318JosefKunz23991078649No11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961078663No456MartinLandolt27351078653No197JosefLang26111078674No216UeliLeuenberger25791078731Yes198FilippoLeutenegger26121078742NT116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291078728No199ChristianLevrat26131078789NT250ArthurLoepfe25111078643No145RicardoLumengo26971078741EH134ChristianLüscher26981078797No251RuediLustenberger25121078697No135PeterMalama26991078733EH38ChristaMarkwalder26141078666No9AdaMarra27261078780No62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161078769Yes243WernerMessmer25181078778No64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701078614Yes367ChristianMiesch23111078737Yes22IsabelleMoret26601078683No244ChristophMörgeli25191078684No12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001078619No188GeriMüller26151078727Yes189PhilippMüller26161078756NT159ThomasMüller26611078725Yes190WalterMüller26171078618No191FelixMüri26181078608NT246JacquesNeirynck25211078640No136YvesNidegger27011078798No175RogerNordmann26481078735NT192RuediNoser26191078645EH137EricNussbaumer27021078601No182GuyParmelin26211078700No247FabioPedrina25221078775Yes313FulvioPelli24091078679No183YvanPerrin26221078739Yes13SylviePerrinjaquet27031078754NT184GerhardPfister26231078648Yes236TheophilPfister25231078631No447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321078770NT415PaulRechsteiner21431078660No304RudolfRechsteiner24121078620Yes138LukasReimann27041078639No305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131078650No187AndréReymond26261078616Yes14NatalieRickli27051078641No139Jean-CharlesRielle27061078795No53KathyRiklin25251078755No176Jean-FrançoisRime26271078744No237MeinradoRobbiani25261078730No238StéphaneRossini25271078785NT239ClaudeRuey25281078749NT173HansRutschmann26441078621No166LouisSchelbert26541078646Yes349SimonSchenk23511078734No29SilviaSchenker26301078751NT240MarcelScherer25291078717No213ErnstSchibli25721078658Yes307UlrichSchlüer24151078712EH15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071078708Yes128RobertoSchmidt27081078777NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301078632No177PirminSchwander26311078716No129PiusSegmüller27091078599P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331078694No178CarloSommaruga26321078761No232PeterSpuhler25351078721NT233JürgStahl25361078622No361LuziStamm23231078692No152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691078672No174HansStöckli26471078704No82DorisStump24211078676No83FranziskaTeuscher24221078774No84AnitaThanei24231078779No300GeorgesTheiler24241078633No7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101078767Yes235PierreTriponez25381078736No163AndyTschümperlin26651078625No126Christianvan Singer27271078626NT180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341078657No181DanielVischer26351078629No130Alecvon Graffenried27111078644No131Christophvon Rotz27121078685No132Erichvon Siebenthal27131078606No133EricVoruz27141078604No295ChristianWaber24491078673No226HansjörgWalter25411078790Yes227HansruediWandfluh25421078695NT124ChristianWasserfallen27151078613No448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331078786No171RetoWehrli26371078682No127ThomasWeibel27281078688No294HansWidmer24461078609NT172WalterWobmann26381078623No8BrigitWyss27161078768No56UrsulaWyss25441078758No168MarkusZemp26561078611No344JosefZisyadis23331078759No219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-19T16:54:43ZArt. 10, al. 1bis, let. bProposition KunzProposition de la commission2047Bundesgesetz über die Reduktion der CO2-Emissionen (CO2-Gesetz) (Anreize für energetisch wirksame Massnahmen im Gebäudebereich)Yes34No129EH4NT32P1Yes34No129EH4NT32ES0P157881078943Yes223FabioAbate25651078834No153AndreasAebi26701078922Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731078902Yes50EviAllemann25831078918No25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711078952Yes30ViolaAmherd26461078987No217AdrianAmstutz25841078864Yes24JosianeAubert26681078996No286CasparBaader24541078950Yes65ElviraBader24741078854No154DominiqueBaettig26731078855Yes26MarliesBänziger26721078906Yes164LucBarthassat26491078907Yes341J. AlexanderBaumann23691078886Yes206MartinBäumle25851078837Yes342DidierBerberat23701078898Yes77MariaBernasconi24361078915No282ElmarBigger24761078838No207AttilioBignasca25861078992No382MaxBinder22701078914Yes155PirminBischof26741078953NT383Roland F.Borer22721078923NT384ToniBortoluzzi22741078903Yes156JacquesBourgeois26751078827NT440DanielBrélaz20231078800Yes48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731078994No343ToniBrunner23721078983No51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871078805Yes208JakobBüchler25881078945No283AndréBugnon24771078896Yes23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661078899No162IgnazioCassis26641078962Yes210SepCathomas25901078889No157TarzisiusCaviezel26771078976Yes272MauriceChevrier24791078862Yes455MaxChopard-Acklin27341078924Yes211AndréDaguet25911078982Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921078946Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931078920Yes222WalterDonzé25641078852No276Jean HenriDunant24841078910Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761078861No16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781078803No327EdiEngelberger23821078988No17YvetteEstermann26791078972Yes79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481078981NT267CharlesFavre24871078810No125LaurentFavre27251078947No328HansFehr23831078966Yes268Hans-JürgFehr24881078932Yes81JacquelineFehr24551078964Yes269MarioFehr24891078893No18DorisFiala26801078856No19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811078859NT202KurtFluri25941078836No330PeterFöhn23851078901Yes146OlivierFrançais26821078913No203OskarFreysinger25951078878Yes40ThereseFrösch25961078887No165LieniFüglistaller26511078871Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541078926Yes41ChantalGalladé25971078957No20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831078802NT204Jean-RenéGermanier25981078963No370UlrichGiezendanner22921078880NT21YvonneGilli26841078817Yes147BastienGirod26851078960Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571078919No10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861078842No261WalterGlur24941078940Yes100ChristineGoll22941078830No148Jean-PierreGraber26871078851Yes46MayaGraf25691078807Yes32EdithGraf-Litscher26521078881NT149Jean-PierreGrin26881078890Yes371AndreasGross22961078867No150HansGrunder26891078965NT422Hans RudolfGysin20771078984Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001078865No58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961078938Yes372AndreaHämmerle22981078948Yes158UrsHany26591078869Yes263HansjörgHassler24971078875No151AlfredHeer26901078870Yes44BeaHeim26011078905Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911078991No325NorbertHochreutener23931078815Yes141AntonioHodgers26921078973No45GabiHuber26021078993EH49RuthHumbel25801078824No142ThomasHurter26931078929No205MarkusHutter26051078911NT35JasminHutter-Hutter26041078891No194OttoIneichen26061078877No256RudolfJoder25021078835Yes31FrancineJohn-Calame26501078847Yes143DanielJositsch26941078828NT257HansKaufmann25031078868Yes36MargretKiener Nellen26081078812No144HansKiller26951078971No37MarianneKleiner26091078909Yes318JosefKunz23991078849Yes11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961078863Yes456MartinLandolt27351078853Yes197JosefLang26111078874Yes216UeliLeuenberger25791078931No198FilippoLeutenegger26121078942Yes116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291078928Yes199ChristianLevrat26131078989NT250ArthurLoepfe25111078843Yes145RicardoLumengo26971078941Yes134ChristianLüscher26981078997Yes251RuediLustenberger25121078897Yes135PeterMalama26991078933No38ChristaMarkwalder26141078866Yes9AdaMarra27261078980Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161078969No243WernerMessmer25181078978Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701078814No367ChristianMiesch23111078937No22IsabelleMoret26601078883No244ChristophMörgeli25191078884Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001078819Yes188GeriMüller26151078927No189PhilippMüller26161078956NT159ThomasMüller26611078925No190WalterMüller26171078818No191FelixMüri26181078808NT246JacquesNeirynck25211078840No136YvesNidegger27011078998Yes175RogerNordmann26481078935NT192RuediNoser26191078845Yes137EricNussbaumer27021078801No182GuyParmelin26211078900Yes247FabioPedrina25221078975No313FulvioPelli24091078879No183YvanPerrin26221078939No13SylviePerrinjaquet27031078954No184GerhardPfister26231078848No236TheophilPfister25231078831Yes447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321078970NT415PaulRechsteiner21431078860Yes304RudolfRechsteiner24121078820No138LukasReimann27041078839Yes305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131078850No187AndréReymond26261078816No14NatalieRickli27051078841Yes139Jean-CharlesRielle27061078995Yes53KathyRiklin25251078955No176Jean-FrançoisRime26271078944Yes237MeinradoRobbiani25261078930Yes238StéphaneRossini25271078985NT239ClaudeRuey25281078949No173HansRutschmann26441078821Yes166LouisSchelbert26541078846No349SimonSchenk23511078934Yes29SilviaSchenker26301078951No240MarcelScherer25291078917No213ErnstSchibli25721078858No307UlrichSchlüer24151078912Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071078908Yes128RobertoSchmidt27081078977NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301078832No177PirminSchwander26311078916Yes129PiusSegmüller27091078799P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331078894Yes178CarloSommaruga26321078961No232PeterSpuhler25351078921NT233JürgStahl25361078822No361LuziStamm23231078892Yes152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691078872NT174HansStöckli26471078904Yes82DorisStump24211078876Yes83FranziskaTeuscher24221078974Yes84AnitaThanei24231078979Yes300GeorgesTheiler24241078833Yes7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101078967No235PierreTriponez25381078936Yes163AndyTschümperlin26651078825Yes126Christianvan Singer27271078826NT180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341078857Yes181DanielVischer26351078829Yes130Alecvon Graffenried27111078844No131Christophvon Rotz27121078885No132Erichvon Siebenthal27131078806Yes133EricVoruz27141078804No295ChristianWaber24491078873No226HansjörgWalter25411078990No227HansruediWandfluh25421078895No124ChristianWasserfallen27151078813Yes448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331078986Yes171RetoWehrli26371078882Yes127ThomasWeibel27281078888Yes294HansWidmer24461078809No172WalterWobmann26381078823Yes8BrigitWyss27161078968Yes56UrsulaWyss25441078958Yes168MarkusZemp26561078811Yes344JosefZisyadis23331078959No219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-19T17:09:33ZArt. 10, al. 1quaterProposition de la minorité Leutengger FilippoProposition de la majorité2048Bundesgesetz über die Reduktion der CO2-Emissionen (CO2-Gesetz) (Anreize für energetisch wirksame Massnahmen im Gebäudebereich)Yes100No77EH1NT21P1Yes100No77EH1NT21ES0P157901079143Yes223FabioAbate25651079034No153AndreasAebi26701079122Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731079102Yes50EviAllemann25831079118No25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711079152Yes30ViolaAmherd26461079187No217AdrianAmstutz25841079064Yes24JosianeAubert26681079196No286CasparBaader24541079150Yes65ElviraBader24741079054No154DominiqueBaettig26731079055Yes26MarliesBänziger26721079106Yes164LucBarthassat26491079107NT341J. AlexanderBaumann23691079086Yes206MartinBäumle25851079037Yes342DidierBerberat23701079098Yes77MariaBernasconi24361079115NT282ElmarBigger24761079038No207AttilioBignasca25861079192No382MaxBinder22701079114Yes155PirminBischof26741079153No383Roland F.Borer22721079123NT384ToniBortoluzzi22741079103Yes156JacquesBourgeois26751079027NT440DanielBrélaz20231079000Yes48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731079194No343ToniBrunner23721079183No51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871079005NT208JakobBüchler25881079145No283AndréBugnon24771079096Yes23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661079099No162IgnazioCassis26641079162Yes210SepCathomas25901079089No157TarzisiusCaviezel26771079176Yes272MauriceChevrier24791079062Yes455MaxChopard-Acklin27341079124Yes211AndréDaguet25911079182Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921079146Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931079120Yes222WalterDonzé25641079052No276Jean HenriDunant24841079110Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761079061EH16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781079003No327EdiEngelberger23821079188No17YvetteEstermann26791079172Yes79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481079181NT267CharlesFavre24871079010No125LaurentFavre27251079147No328HansFehr23831079166Yes268Hans-JürgFehr24881079132Yes81JacquelineFehr24551079164Yes269MarioFehr24891079093No18DorisFiala26801079056No19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811079059NT202KurtFluri25941079036NT330PeterFöhn23851079101Yes146OlivierFrançais26821079113No203OskarFreysinger25951079078Yes40ThereseFrösch25961079087No165LieniFüglistaller26511079071Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541079126Yes41ChantalGalladé25971079157No20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831079002NT204Jean-RenéGermanier25981079163No370UlrichGiezendanner22921079080NT21YvonneGilli26841079017Yes147BastienGirod26851079160Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571079119No10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861079042No261WalterGlur24941079140Yes100ChristineGoll22941079030NT148Jean-PierreGraber26871079051Yes46MayaGraf25691079007Yes32EdithGraf-Litscher26521079081No149Jean-PierreGrin26881079090Yes371AndreasGross22961079067NT150HansGrunder26891079165NT422Hans RudolfGysin20771079184Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001079065NT58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961079138Yes372AndreaHämmerle22981079148Yes158UrsHany26591079069Yes263HansjörgHassler24971079075No151AlfredHeer26901079070Yes44BeaHeim26011079105Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911079191No325NorbertHochreutener23931079015Yes141AntonioHodgers26921079173No45GabiHuber26021079193Yes49RuthHumbel25801079024No142ThomasHurter26931079129No205MarkusHutter26051079111No35JasminHutter-Hutter26041079091Yes194OttoIneichen26061079077No256RudolfJoder25021079035Yes31FrancineJohn-Calame26501079047Yes143DanielJositsch26941079028NT257HansKaufmann25031079068Yes36MargretKiener Nellen26081079012No144HansKiller26951079171No37MarianneKleiner26091079109EH318JosefKunz23991079049Yes11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961079063Yes456MartinLandolt27351079053Yes197JosefLang26111079074Yes216UeliLeuenberger25791079131No198FilippoLeutenegger26121079142Yes116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291079128Yes199ChristianLevrat26131079189NT250ArthurLoepfe25111079043Yes145RicardoLumengo26971079141EH134ChristianLüscher26981079197Yes251RuediLustenberger25121079097Yes135PeterMalama26991079133EH38ChristaMarkwalder26141079066Yes9AdaMarra27261079180Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161079169No243WernerMessmer25181079178Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701079014No367ChristianMiesch23111079137No22IsabelleMoret26601079083NT244ChristophMörgeli25191079084Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001079019Yes188GeriMüller26151079127No189PhilippMüller26161079156NT159ThomasMüller26611079125No190WalterMüller26171079018No191FelixMüri26181079008NT246JacquesNeirynck25211079040No136YvesNidegger27011079198Yes175RogerNordmann26481079135NT192RuediNoser26191079045Yes137EricNussbaumer27021079001No182GuyParmelin26211079100Yes247FabioPedrina25221079175No313FulvioPelli24091079079No183YvanPerrin26221079139No13SylviePerrinjaquet27031079154No184GerhardPfister26231079048No236TheophilPfister25231079031Yes447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321079170NT415PaulRechsteiner21431079060Yes304RudolfRechsteiner24121079020No138LukasReimann27041079039Yes305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131079050No187AndréReymond26261079016NT14NatalieRickli27051079041Yes139Jean-CharlesRielle27061079195Yes53KathyRiklin25251079155No176Jean-FrançoisRime26271079144Yes237MeinradoRobbiani25261079130Yes238StéphaneRossini25271079185NT239ClaudeRuey25281079149No173HansRutschmann26441079021Yes166LouisSchelbert26541079046No349SimonSchenk23511079134Yes29SilviaSchenker26301079151No240MarcelScherer25291079117No213ErnstSchibli25721079058No307UlrichSchlüer24151079112Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071079108NT128RobertoSchmidt27081079177NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301079032No177PirminSchwander26311079116Yes129PiusSegmüller27091078999P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331079094Yes178CarloSommaruga26321079161NT232PeterSpuhler25351079121NT233JürgStahl25361079022NT361LuziStamm23231079092Yes152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691079072NT174HansStöckli26471079104Yes82DorisStump24211079076Yes83FranziskaTeuscher24221079174Yes84AnitaThanei24231079179Yes300GeorgesTheiler24241079033Yes7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101079167No235PierreTriponez25381079136Yes163AndyTschümperlin26651079025Yes126Christianvan Singer27271079026NT180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341079057Yes181DanielVischer26351079029Yes130Alecvon Graffenried27111079044No131Christophvon Rotz27121079085NT132Erichvon Siebenthal27131079006Yes133EricVoruz27141079004No295ChristianWaber24491079073No226HansjörgWalter25411079190No227HansruediWandfluh25421079095No124ChristianWasserfallen27151079013Yes448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331079186Yes171RetoWehrli26371079082Yes127ThomasWeibel27281079088Yes294HansWidmer24461079009No172WalterWobmann26381079023Yes8BrigitWyss27161079168Yes56UrsulaWyss25441079158Yes168MarkusZemp26561079011Yes344JosefZisyadis23331079159No219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-19T17:25:50ZArt. 10, al. 1quinquiesProposition de la minorité AmstutzProposition de la majorité2050Bundesgesetz über die Reduktion der CO2-Emissionen (CO2-Gesetz) (Anreize für energetisch wirksame Massnahmen im Gebäudebereich)Yes97No67EH4NT31P1Yes97No67EH4NT31ES0P157911079343Yes223FabioAbate25651079234Yes153AndreasAebi26701079322No281RuediAeschbacher24731079302Yes50EviAllemann25831079318Yes25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711079352Yes30ViolaAmherd26461079387Yes217AdrianAmstutz25841079264No24JosianeAubert26681079396Yes286CasparBaader24541079350Yes65ElviraBader24741079254Yes154DominiqueBaettig26731079255No26MarliesBänziger26721079306EH164LucBarthassat26491079307Yes341J. AlexanderBaumann23691079286No206MartinBäumle25851079237No342DidierBerberat23701079298EH77MariaBernasconi24361079315Yes282ElmarBigger24761079238Yes207AttilioBignasca25861079392Yes382MaxBinder22701079314Yes155PirminBischof26741079353Yes383Roland F.Borer22721079323NT384ToniBortoluzzi22741079303Yes156JacquesBourgeois26751079227NT440DanielBrélaz20231079200EH48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731079394Yes343ToniBrunner23721079383Yes51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871079205NT208JakobBüchler25881079345Yes283AndréBugnon24771079296Yes23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661079299Yes162IgnazioCassis26641079362No210SepCathomas25901079289Yes157TarzisiusCaviezel26771079376Yes272MauriceChevrier24791079262No455MaxChopard-Acklin27341079324Yes211AndréDaguet25911079382Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921079346Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931079320No222WalterDonzé25641079252Yes276Jean HenriDunant24841079310Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761079261Yes16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781079203Yes327EdiEngelberger23821079388Yes17YvetteEstermann26791079372No79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481079381NT267CharlesFavre24871079210Yes125LaurentFavre27251079347Yes328HansFehr23831079366Yes268Hans-JürgFehr24881079332Yes81JacquelineFehr24551079364No269MarioFehr24891079293Yes18DorisFiala26801079256Yes19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811079259NT202KurtFluri25941079236NT330PeterFöhn23851079301Yes146OlivierFrançais26821079313Yes203OskarFreysinger25951079278No40ThereseFrösch25961079287Yes165LieniFüglistaller26511079271Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541079326Yes41ChantalGalladé25971079357Yes20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831079202NT204Jean-RenéGermanier25981079363Yes370UlrichGiezendanner22921079280NT21YvonneGilli26841079217No147BastienGirod26851079360No33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571079319Yes10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861079242Yes261WalterGlur24941079340No100ChristineGoll22941079230Yes148Jean-PierreGraber26871079251No46MayaGraf25691079207Yes32EdithGraf-Litscher26521079281Yes149Jean-PierreGrin26881079290No371AndreasGross22961079267Yes150HansGrunder26891079365NT422Hans RudolfGysin20771079384Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001079265Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961079338EH372AndreaHämmerle22981079348Yes158UrsHany26591079269Yes263HansjörgHassler24971079275Yes151AlfredHeer26901079270No44BeaHeim26011079305Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911079391NT325NorbertHochreutener23931079215No141AntonioHodgers26921079373Yes45GabiHuber26021079393No49RuthHumbel25801079224Yes142ThomasHurter26931079329Yes205MarkusHutter26051079311Yes35JasminHutter-Hutter26041079291Yes194OttoIneichen26061079277Yes256RudolfJoder25021079235No31FrancineJohn-Calame26501079247Yes143DanielJositsch26941079228NT257HansKaufmann25031079268No36MargretKiener Nellen26081079212Yes144HansKiller26951079371Yes37MarianneKleiner26091079309Yes318JosefKunz23991079249No11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961079263NT456MartinLandolt27351079253No197JosefLang26111079274No216UeliLeuenberger25791079331Yes198FilippoLeutenegger26121079342Yes116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291079328No199ChristianLevrat26131079389NT250ArthurLoepfe25111079243Yes145RicardoLumengo26971079341Yes134ChristianLüscher26981079397No251RuediLustenberger25121079297Yes135PeterMalama26991079333Yes38ChristaMarkwalder26141079266No9AdaMarra27261079380Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161079369Yes243WernerMessmer25181079378Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701079214Yes367ChristianMiesch23111079337Yes22IsabelleMoret26601079283Yes244ChristophMörgeli25191079284No12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001079219No188GeriMüller26151079327Yes189PhilippMüller26161079356NT159ThomasMüller26611079325Yes190WalterMüller26171079218Yes191FelixMüri26181079208NT246JacquesNeirynck25211079240Yes136YvesNidegger27011079398No175RogerNordmann26481079335NT192RuediNoser26191079245No137EricNussbaumer27021079201Yes182GuyParmelin26211079300Yes247FabioPedrina25221079375Yes313FulvioPelli24091079279Yes183YvanPerrin26221079339Yes13SylviePerrinjaquet27031079354Yes184GerhardPfister26231079248Yes236TheophilPfister25231079231No447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321079370NT415PaulRechsteiner21431079260No304RudolfRechsteiner24121079220Yes138LukasReimann27041079239NT305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131079250Yes187AndréReymond26261079216Yes14NatalieRickli27051079241Yes139Jean-CharlesRielle27061079395No53KathyRiklin25251079355Yes176Jean-FrançoisRime26271079344Yes237MeinradoRobbiani25261079330No238StéphaneRossini25271079385NT239ClaudeRuey25281079349Yes173HansRutschmann26441079221Yes166LouisSchelbert26541079246Yes349SimonSchenk23511079334Yes29SilviaSchenker26301079351Yes240MarcelScherer25291079317Yes213ErnstSchibli25721079258Yes307UlrichSchlüer24151079312Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071079308Yes128RobertoSchmidt27081079377NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301079232Yes177PirminSchwander26311079316No129PiusSegmüller27091079199P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331079294Yes178CarloSommaruga26321079361Yes232PeterSpuhler25351079321NT233JürgStahl25361079222Yes361LuziStamm23231079292Yes152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691079272NT174HansStöckli26471079304Yes82DorisStump24211079276No83FranziskaTeuscher24221079374Yes84AnitaThanei24231079379Yes300GeorgesTheiler24241079233No7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101079367Yes235PierreTriponez25381079336Yes163AndyTschümperlin26651079225No126Christianvan Singer27271079226NT180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341079257No181DanielVischer26351079229No130Alecvon Graffenried27111079244Yes131Christophvon Rotz27121079285Yes132Erichvon Siebenthal27131079206No133EricVoruz27141079204Yes295ChristianWaber24491079273Yes226HansjörgWalter25411079390Yes227HansruediWandfluh25421079295Yes124ChristianWasserfallen27151079213Yes448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331079386Yes171RetoWehrli26371079282No127ThomasWeibel27281079288Yes294HansWidmer24461079209Yes172WalterWobmann26381079223Yes8BrigitWyss27161079368Yes56UrsulaWyss25441079358NT168MarkusZemp26561079211No344JosefZisyadis23331079359Yes219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-19T17:30:10ZArt. 257a, al. 3Proposition de la minorité BäumleProposition de la majorité2051Bundesgesetz über die Reduktion der CO2-Emissionen (CO2-Gesetz) (Anreize für energetisch wirksame Massnahmen im Gebäudebereich)Yes127No44EH4NT24P1Yes127No44EH4NT24ES0P157921079543Yes223FabioAbate25651079434Yes153AndreasAebi26701079522Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731079502Yes50EviAllemann25831079518No25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711079552Yes30ViolaAmherd26461079587No217AdrianAmstutz25841079464Yes24JosianeAubert26681079596No286CasparBaader24541079550Yes65ElviraBader24741079454Yes154DominiqueBaettig26731079455Yes26MarliesBänziger26721079506Yes164LucBarthassat26491079507No341J. AlexanderBaumann23691079486Yes206MartinBäumle25851079437Yes342DidierBerberat23701079498Yes77MariaBernasconi24361079515No282ElmarBigger24761079438No207AttilioBignasca25861079592No382MaxBinder22701079514Yes155PirminBischof26741079553No383Roland F.Borer22721079523NT384ToniBortoluzzi22741079503Yes156JacquesBourgeois26751079427NT440DanielBrélaz20231079400Yes48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731079594No343ToniBrunner23721079583No51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871079405NT208JakobBüchler25881079545No283AndréBugnon24771079496Yes23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661079499EH162IgnazioCassis26641079562Yes210SepCathomas25901079489EH157TarzisiusCaviezel26771079576Yes272MauriceChevrier24791079462Yes455MaxChopard-Acklin27341079524Yes211AndréDaguet25911079582Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921079546Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931079520Yes222WalterDonzé25641079452No276Jean HenriDunant24841079510Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761079461EH16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781079403No327EdiEngelberger23821079588No17YvetteEstermann26791079572Yes79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481079581NT267CharlesFavre24871079410Yes125LaurentFavre27251079547No328HansFehr23831079566Yes268Hans-JürgFehr24881079532Yes81JacquelineFehr24551079564Yes269MarioFehr24891079493No18DorisFiala26801079456Yes19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811079459NT202KurtFluri25941079436NT330PeterFöhn23851079501Yes146OlivierFrançais26821079513Yes203OskarFreysinger25951079478Yes40ThereseFrösch25961079487No165LieniFüglistaller26511079471Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541079526Yes41ChantalGalladé25971079557EH20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831079402NT204Jean-RenéGermanier25981079563No370UlrichGiezendanner22921079480NT21YvonneGilli26841079417Yes147BastienGirod26851079560Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571079519Yes10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861079442No261WalterGlur24941079540Yes100ChristineGoll22941079430No148Jean-PierreGraber26871079451Yes46MayaGraf25691079407Yes32EdithGraf-Litscher26521079481Yes149Jean-PierreGrin26881079490Yes371AndreasGross22961079467Yes150HansGrunder26891079565NT422Hans RudolfGysin20771079584Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001079465Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961079538Yes372AndreaHämmerle22981079548Yes158UrsHany26591079469Yes263HansjörgHassler24971079475No151AlfredHeer26901079470Yes44BeaHeim26011079505Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911079591Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931079415Yes141AntonioHodgers26921079573No45GabiHuber26021079593Yes49RuthHumbel25801079424No142ThomasHurter26931079529No205MarkusHutter26051079511No35JasminHutter-Hutter26041079491Yes194OttoIneichen26061079477Yes256RudolfJoder25021079435Yes31FrancineJohn-Calame26501079447Yes143DanielJositsch26941079428NT257HansKaufmann25031079468Yes36MargretKiener Nellen26081079412No144HansKiller26951079571No37MarianneKleiner26091079509Yes318JosefKunz23991079449Yes11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961079463NT456MartinLandolt27351079453Yes197JosefLang26111079474Yes216UeliLeuenberger25791079531No198FilippoLeutenegger26121079542Yes116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291079528Yes199ChristianLevrat26131079589NT250ArthurLoepfe25111079443Yes145RicardoLumengo26971079541EH134ChristianLüscher26981079597Yes251RuediLustenberger25121079497Yes135PeterMalama26991079533Yes38ChristaMarkwalder26141079466Yes9AdaMarra27261079580Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161079569No243WernerMessmer25181079578Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701079414No367ChristianMiesch23111079537EH22IsabelleMoret26601079483No244ChristophMörgeli25191079484Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001079419Yes188GeriMüller26151079527No189PhilippMüller26161079556NT159ThomasMüller26611079525No190WalterMüller26171079418No191FelixMüri26181079408NT246JacquesNeirynck25211079440No136YvesNidegger27011079598Yes175RogerNordmann26481079535NT192RuediNoser26191079445Yes137EricNussbaumer27021079401No182GuyParmelin26211079500Yes247FabioPedrina25221079575No313FulvioPelli24091079479Yes183YvanPerrin26221079539No13SylviePerrinjaquet27031079554NT184GerhardPfister26231079448No236TheophilPfister25231079431Yes447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321079570NT415PaulRechsteiner21431079460Yes304RudolfRechsteiner24121079420No138LukasReimann27041079439Yes305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131079450No187AndréReymond26261079416No14NatalieRickli27051079441Yes139Jean-CharlesRielle27061079595Yes53KathyRiklin25251079555Yes176Jean-FrançoisRime26271079544Yes237MeinradoRobbiani25261079530Yes238StéphaneRossini25271079585NT239ClaudeRuey25281079549No173HansRutschmann26441079421Yes166LouisSchelbert26541079446No349SimonSchenk23511079534Yes29SilviaSchenker26301079551No240MarcelScherer25291079517No213ErnstSchibli25721079458No307UlrichSchlüer24151079512Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071079508Yes128RobertoSchmidt27081079577NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301079432No177PirminSchwander26311079516Yes129PiusSegmüller27091079399P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331079494Yes178CarloSommaruga26321079561No232PeterSpuhler25351079521NT233JürgStahl25361079422No361LuziStamm23231079492Yes152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691079472NT174HansStöckli26471079504Yes82DorisStump24211079476Yes83FranziskaTeuscher24221079574Yes84AnitaThanei24231079579Yes300GeorgesTheiler24241079433Yes7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101079567No235PierreTriponez25381079536Yes163AndyTschümperlin26651079425Yes126Christianvan Singer27271079426NT180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341079457Yes181DanielVischer26351079429Yes130Alecvon Graffenried27111079444No131Christophvon Rotz27121079485Yes132Erichvon Siebenthal27131079406Yes133EricVoruz27141079404No295ChristianWaber24491079473NT226HansjörgWalter25411079590No227HansruediWandfluh25421079495No124ChristianWasserfallen27151079413Yes448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331079586Yes171RetoWehrli26371079482Yes127ThomasWeibel27281079488Yes294HansWidmer24461079409No172WalterWobmann26381079423Yes8BrigitWyss27161079568Yes56UrsulaWyss25441079558Yes168MarkusZemp26561079411Yes344JosefZisyadis23331079559No219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-19T17:31:08ZVote sur l'ensemble2052Bundesgesetz über die Reduktion der CO2-Emissionen (CO2-Gesetz) (Anreize für energetisch wirksame Massnahmen im Gebäudebereich)Yes113No57EH6NT23P1Yes113No57EH6NT23ES0P161031134543Yes223FabioAbate25651134434No153AndreasAebi26701134522Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731134502Yes50EviAllemann25831134518Yes25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711134552Yes30ViolaAmherd26461134587No217AdrianAmstutz25841134464Yes24JosianeAubert26681134596No286CasparBaader24541134550Yes65ElviraBader24741134454No154DominiqueBaettig26731134455Yes26MarliesBänziger26721134506Yes164LucBarthassat26491134507No341J. AlexanderBaumann23691134486Yes206MartinBäumle25851134437Yes342DidierBerberat23701134498Yes77MariaBernasconi24361134515No282ElmarBigger24761134438NT207AttilioBignasca25861134592No382MaxBinder22701134514Yes155PirminBischof26741134553No383Roland F.Borer22721134523No384ToniBortoluzzi22741134503Yes156JacquesBourgeois26751134427NT440DanielBrélaz20231134400Yes48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731134594No343ToniBrunner23721134583Yes51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871134405Yes208JakobBüchler25881134545No283AndréBugnon24771134496Yes23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661134499NT162IgnazioCassis26641134562Yes210SepCathomas25901134489Yes157TarzisiusCaviezel26771134576Yes272MauriceChevrier24791134462Yes455MaxChopard-Acklin27341134524Yes211AndréDaguet25911134582NT200ChristopheDarbellay25921134546NT201Dominiquede Buman25931134520Yes222WalterDonzé25641134452No276Jean HenriDunant24841134510NT27EstherEgger-Wyss26761134461Yes16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781134403Yes327EdiEngelberger23821134588No17YvetteEstermann26791134572Yes79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481134581Yes267CharlesFavre24871134410Yes125LaurentFavre27251134547NT328HansFehr23831134566Yes268Hans-JürgFehr24881134532Yes81JacquelineFehr24551134564Yes269MarioFehr24891134493Yes18DorisFiala26801134456EH19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811134459Yes202KurtFluri25941134436No330PeterFöhn23851134501Yes146OlivierFrançais26821134513No203OskarFreysinger25951134478Yes40ThereseFrösch25961134487No165LieniFüglistaller26511134471Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541134526Yes41ChantalGalladé25971134557No20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831134402NT204Jean-RenéGermanier25981134563No370UlrichGiezendanner22921134480Yes21YvonneGilli26841134417Yes147BastienGirod26851134560Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571134519No10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861134442No261WalterGlur24941134540Yes100ChristineGoll22941134430No148Jean-PierreGraber26871134451Yes46MayaGraf25691134407Yes32EdithGraf-Litscher26521134481No149Jean-PierreGrin26881134490Yes371AndreasGross22961134467Yes150HansGrunder26891134565Yes422Hans RudolfGysin20771134584Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001134465Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961134538Yes372AndreaHämmerle22981134548Yes158UrsHany26591134469Yes263HansjörgHassler24971134475No151AlfredHeer26901134470Yes44BeaHeim26011134505Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911134591Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931134415Yes141AntonioHodgers26921134573Yes45GabiHuber26021134593Yes49RuthHumbel25801134424No142ThomasHurter26931134529NT205MarkusHutter26051134511No35JasminHutter-Hutter26041134491Yes194OttoIneichen26061134477No256RudolfJoder25021134435Yes31FrancineJohn-Calame26501134447Yes143DanielJositsch26941134428No257HansKaufmann25031134468Yes36MargretKiener Nellen26081134412No144HansKiller26951134571Yes37MarianneKleiner26091134509EH318JosefKunz23991134449Yes11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961134463Yes456MartinLandolt27351134453Yes197JosefLang26111134474Yes216UeliLeuenberger25791134531No198FilippoLeutenegger26121134542Yes116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291134528Yes199ChristianLevrat26131134589NT250ArthurLoepfe25111134443Yes145RicardoLumengo26971134541NT134ChristianLüscher26981134598Yes251RuediLustenberger25121134497NT135PeterMalama26991134533Yes38ChristaMarkwalder26141134466Yes9AdaMarra27261134580Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161134569Yes243WernerMessmer25181134578Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701134414No367ChristianMiesch23111134537Yes22IsabelleMoret26601134483No244ChristophMörgeli25191134484Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001134419Yes188GeriMüller26151134527Yes189PhilippMüller26161134556No159ThomasMüller26611134525Yes190WalterMüller26171134418No191FelixMüri26181134408NT246JacquesNeirynck25211134440No136YvesNidegger27011134597Yes175RogerNordmann26481134535Yes192RuediNoser26191134445Yes137EricNussbaumer27021134401No182GuyParmelin26211134500Yes247FabioPedrina25221134575Yes313FulvioPelli24091134479No183YvanPerrin26221134539NT13SylviePerrinjaquet27031134554No184GerhardPfister26231134448No236TheophilPfister25231134431Yes447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321134570NT415PaulRechsteiner21431134460Yes304RudolfRechsteiner24121134420No138LukasReimann27041134439Yes305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131134450No187AndréReymond26261134416No14NatalieRickli27051134441Yes139Jean-CharlesRielle27061134595Yes53KathyRiklin25251134555No176Jean-FrançoisRime26271134544Yes237MeinradoRobbiani25261134530Yes238StéphaneRossini25271134585NT239ClaudeRuey25281134549No173HansRutschmann26441134421Yes166LouisSchelbert26541134446No349SimonSchenk23511134534Yes29SilviaSchenker26301134551No240MarcelScherer25291134517No213ErnstSchibli25721134458No307UlrichSchlüer24151134512Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071134508Yes128RobertoSchmidt27081134577NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301134432No177PirminSchwander26311134516EH129PiusSegmüller27091134399P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331134494NT178CarloSommaruga26321134561NT232PeterSpuhler25351134521No233JürgStahl25361134422NT361LuziStamm23231134492NT152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691134472NT174HansStöckli26471134504Yes82DorisStump24211134476Yes83FranziskaTeuscher24221134574Yes84AnitaThanei24231134579NT300GeorgesTheiler24241134433Yes7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101134567Yes235PierreTriponez25381134536Yes163AndyTschümperlin26651134425Yes126Christianvan Singer27271134426No180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341134457Yes181DanielVischer26351134429Yes130Alecvon Graffenried27111134444No131Christophvon Rotz27121134485EH132Erichvon Siebenthal27131134406Yes133EricVoruz27141134404No295ChristianWaber24491134473No226HansjörgWalter25411134590NT227HansruediWandfluh25421134495No124ChristianWasserfallen27151134413Yes448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331134586Yes171RetoWehrli26371134482Yes127ThomasWeibel27281134488Yes294HansWidmer24461134409No172WalterWobmann26381134423Yes8BrigitWyss27161134568NT56UrsulaWyss25441134558Yes168MarkusZemp26561134411Yes344JosefZisyadis23331134559No219BrunoZuppiger25472009-06-02T18:01:42ZArt. 10, al. 1quater (vaut également pour l'art. 15bis)Proposition de la minorité RutschmannProposition de la majorité2363Bundesgesetz über die Reduktion der CO2-Emissionen (CO2-Gesetz) (Anreize für energetisch wirksame Massnahmen im Gebäudebereich)Yes114No56EH4NT25P1Yes114No56EH4NT25ES0P16329false1172544EH223FabioAbate25651172434EH153AndreasAebi26701172523Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731172503Yes50EviAllemann25831172519EH25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711172553Yes30ViolaAmherd26461172588No217AdrianAmstutz25841172465Yes24JosianeAubert26681172598No286CasparBaader24541172551Yes65ElviraBader24741172454No154DominiqueBaettig26731172455Yes26MarliesBänziger26721172507NT164LucBarthassat26491172508No341J. AlexanderBaumann23691172487Yes206MartinBäumle25851172437Yes342DidierBerberat23701172499Yes77MariaBernasconi24361172516No282ElmarBigger24761172438No207AttilioBignasca25861172594No382MaxBinder22701172515NT155PirminBischof26741172554No383Roland F.Borer22721172524No384ToniBortoluzzi22741172504EH156JacquesBourgeois26751172427Yes440DanielBrélaz20231172400Yes48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731172596No343ToniBrunner23721172584No51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871172405Yes208JakobBüchler25881172546No283AndréBugnon24771172497Yes23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661172500EH162IgnazioCassis26641172563Yes210SepCathomas25901172490No157TarzisiusCaviezel26771172577Yes272MauriceChevrier24791172463Yes455MaxChopard-Acklin27341172525Yes211AndréDaguet25911172583Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921172547Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931172521Yes222WalterDonzé25641172452No276Jean HenriDunant24841172511Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761172462EH16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781172403No327EdiEngelberger23821172590No17YvetteEstermann26791172573Yes79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481172582No267CharlesFavre24871172410EH125LaurentFavre27251172548No328HansFehr23831172567Yes268Hans-JürgFehr24881172533Yes81JacquelineFehr24551172565Yes269MarioFehr24891172494NT18DorisFiala26801172456Yes19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811172460No202KurtFluri25941172436No330PeterFöhn23851172502NT146OlivierFrançais26821172514No203OskarFreysinger25951172479Yes40ThereseFrösch25961172488No165LieniFüglistaller26511172472Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541172527Yes41ChantalGalladé25971172558EH20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831172402No204Jean-RenéGermanier25981172564No370UlrichGiezendanner22921172481Yes21YvonneGilli26841172417Yes147BastienGirod26851172561Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571172520EH10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861172442No261WalterGlur24941172541Yes100ChristineGoll22941172430No148Jean-PierreGraber26871172451Yes46MayaGraf25691172407Yes32EdithGraf-Litscher26521172482EH149Jean-PierreGrin26881172491ES371AndreasGross22961172468Yes150HansGrunder26891172566EH422Hans RudolfGysin20771172585Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001172466Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961172539Yes372AndreaHämmerle22981172549Yes158UrsHany26591172470Yes263HansjörgHassler24971172476No151AlfredHeer26901172471Yes44BeaHeim26011172506EH140HuguesHiltpold26911172593Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931172415Yes141AntonioHodgers26921172574No45GabiHuber26021172595Yes49RuthHumbel25801172424No142ThomasHurter26931172530No205MarkusHutter26051172512No35JasminHutter-Hutter26041172492Yes194OttoIneichen26061172478No256RudolfJoder25021172435Yes31FrancineJohn-Calame26501172447Yes143DanielJositsch26941172428No257HansKaufmann25031172469Yes36MargretKiener Nellen26081172412No144HansKiller26951172572No37MarianneKleiner26091172510Yes318JosefKunz23991172449Yes11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961172464Yes456MartinLandolt27351172453Yes197JosefLang26111172475Yes216UeliLeuenberger25791172532No198FilippoLeutenegger26121172543Yes116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291172529Yes199ChristianLevrat26131172591No250ArthurLoepfe25111172443Yes145RicardoLumengo26971172542No134ChristianLüscher26981172589Yes251RuediLustenberger25121172498EH135PeterMalama26991172534EH38ChristaMarkwalder26141172467Yes9AdaMarra27261172581Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161172570No243WernerMessmer25181172579Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701172414No367ChristianMiesch23111172538EH22IsabelleMoret26601172484No244ChristophMörgeli25191172485Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001172419Yes188GeriMüller26151172528No189PhilippMüller26161172557Yes159ThomasMüller26611172526No190WalterMüller26171172418No191FelixMüri26181172408Yes246JacquesNeirynck25211172440No136YvesNidegger27011172459Yes175RogerNordmann26481172536NT192RuediNoser26191172445Yes137EricNussbaumer27021172401No182GuyParmelin26211172501Yes247FabioPedrina25221172576No313FulvioPelli24091172480No183YvanPerrin26221172540No13SylviePerrinjaquet27031172555No184GerhardPfister26231172448No236TheophilPfister25231172431Yes447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321172571Yes415PaulRechsteiner21431172461Yes304RudolfRechsteiner24121172420No138LukasReimann27041172439Yes305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131172450No187AndréReymond26261172416No14NatalieRickli27051172441Yes139Jean-CharlesRielle27061172597Yes53KathyRiklin25251172556Yes176Jean-FrançoisRime26271172545Yes237MeinradoRobbiani25261172531Yes238StéphaneRossini25271172586No239ClaudeRuey25281172550No173HansRutschmann26441172421Yes166LouisSchelbert26541172446No349SimonSchenk23511172535Yes29SilviaSchenker26301172552No240MarcelScherer25291172518No213ErnstSchibli25721172458No307UlrichSchlüer24151172513Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071172509Yes128RobertoSchmidt27081172578No241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301172432No177PirminSchwander26311172517Yes129PiusSegmüller27091172399P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331172495Yes178CarloSommaruga26321172562No232PeterSpuhler25351172522No233JürgStahl25361172422No361LuziStamm23231172493Yes152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691172473NT174HansStöckli26471172505Yes82DorisStump24211172477Yes83FranziskaTeuscher24221172575Yes84AnitaThanei24231172580Yes300GeorgesTheiler24241172433Yes7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101172568No235PierreTriponez25381172537Yes163AndyTschümperlin26651172425Yes126Christianvan Singer27271172426No180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341172457Yes181DanielVischer26351172429Yes130Alecvon Graffenried27111172444No131Christophvon Rotz27121172486EH132Erichvon Siebenthal27131172406Yes133EricVoruz27141172404No295ChristianWaber24491172474No226HansjörgWalter25411172592No227HansruediWandfluh25421172496No124ChristianWasserfallen27151172413Yes448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331172587Yes171RetoWehrli26371172483Yes127ThomasWeibel27281172489Yes294HansWidmer24461172409No172WalterWobmann26381172423Yes8BrigitWyss27161172569Yes56UrsulaWyss25441172559Yes168MarkusZemp26561172411Yes344JosefZisyadis23331172560No219BrunoZuppiger25472009-06-12T10:23:58ZVote final2589Bundesgesetz über die Reduktion der CO2-Emissionen (CO2-Gesetz) (Anreize für energetisch wirksame Massnahmen im Gebäudebereich)Yes102No74EH16NT6ES1P1Yes102No74EH16NT6ES1P1