200800682026-04-18T03:05:05Z56961062343Yes223FabioAbate25651062234Yes153AndreasAebi26701062322Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731062302No50EviAllemann25831062318NT25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711062352Yes30ViolaAmherd26461062386Yes217AdrianAmstutz25841062265No24JosianeAubert26681062396Yes286CasparBaader24541062350Yes65ElviraBader24741062254Yes154DominiqueBaettig26731062255No26MarliesBänziger26721062306Yes164LucBarthassat26491062307NT341J. AlexanderBaumann23691062286Yes206MartinBäumle25851062237No342DidierBerberat23701062298No77MariaBernasconi24361062315Yes282ElmarBigger24761062238Yes207AttilioBignasca25861062392Yes382MaxBinder22701062314NT155PirminBischof26741062353Yes383Roland F.Borer22721062323Yes384ToniBortoluzzi22741062303Yes156JacquesBourgeois26751062227No440DanielBrélaz20231062200No48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731062394Yes343ToniBrunner23721062382NT51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871062205Yes208JakobBüchler25881062345Yes283AndréBugnon24771062296No23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661062299Yes162IgnazioCassis26641062361NT210SepCathomas25901062289Yes157TarzisiusCaviezel26771062375Yes272MauriceChevrier24791062263No455MaxChopard-Acklin27341062324No211AndréDaguet25911062381Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921062346Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931062320Yes222WalterDonzé25641062252Yes276Jean HenriDunant24841062310Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761062262Yes16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781062203Yes327EdiEngelberger23821062388Yes17YvetteEstermann26791062371No79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481062380Yes267CharlesFavre24871062210Yes125LaurentFavre27251062347Yes328HansFehr23831062365No268Hans-JürgFehr24881062332No81JacquelineFehr24551062363No269MarioFehr24891062293NT18DorisFiala26801062256Yes19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811062260Yes202KurtFluri25941062236Yes330PeterFöhn23851062301Yes146OlivierFrançais26821062313Yes203OskarFreysinger25951062279No40ThereseFrösch25961062287Yes165LieniFüglistaller26511062272Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541062326No41ChantalGalladé25971062356Yes20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831062202NT204Jean-RenéGermanier25981062362Yes370UlrichGiezendanner22921062281No21YvonneGilli26841062217No147BastienGirod26851062359Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571062319Yes10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861062242Yes261WalterGlur24941062340No100ChristineGoll22941062230Yes148Jean-PierreGraber26871062251No46MayaGraf25691062207NT32EdithGraf-Litscher26521062397Yes149Jean-PierreGrin26881062290ES371AndreasGross22961062268Yes150HansGrunder26891062364NT422Hans RudolfGysin20771062383Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001062266Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961062338No372AndreaHämmerle22981062348Yes158UrsHany26591062270Yes263HansjörgHassler24971062276Yes151AlfredHeer26901062271No44BeaHeim26011062305Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911062391Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931062215No141AntonioHodgers26921062372Yes45GabiHuber26021062393Yes49RuthHumbel25801062224Yes142ThomasHurter26931062329Yes205MarkusHutter26051062311Yes35JasminHutter-Hutter26041062291NT194OttoIneichen26061062278Yes256RudolfJoder25021062235NT31FrancineJohn-Calame26501062247No143DanielJositsch26941062228Yes257HansKaufmann25031062269No36MargretKiener Nellen26081062212Yes144HansKiller26951062370Yes37MarianneKleiner26091062309NT318JosefKunz23991062249No11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961062264Yes456MartinLandolt27351062253No197JosefLang26111062275No216UeliLeuenberger25791062331Yes198FilippoLeutenegger26121062342NT116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291062328No199ChristianLevrat26131062389Yes250ArthurLoepfe25111062243No145RicardoLumengo26971062341Yes134ChristianLüscher26981062387Yes251RuediLustenberger25121062297Yes135PeterMalama26991062333Yes38ChristaMarkwalder26141062267No9AdaMarra27261062379Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161062368Yes243WernerMessmer25181062377NT64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701062214Yes367ChristianMiesch23111062337Yes22IsabelleMoret26601062283NT244ChristophMörgeli25191062284Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001062219No188GeriMüller26151062327Yes189PhilippMüller26161062398Yes159ThomasMüller26611062325Yes190WalterMüller26171062218Yes191FelixMüri26181062208Yes246JacquesNeirynck25211062240Yes136YvesNidegger27011062259No175RogerNordmann26481062335NT192RuediNoser26191062245NT137EricNussbaumer27021062201Yes182GuyParmelin26211062300No247FabioPedrina25221062374Yes313FulvioPelli24091062280Yes183YvanPerrin26221062339NT13SylviePerrinjaquet27031062354Yes184GerhardPfister26231062248Yes236TheophilPfister25231062231No447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321062369No415PaulRechsteiner21431062261No304RudolfRechsteiner24121062220Yes138LukasReimann27041062239No305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131062250Yes187AndréReymond26261062216Yes14NatalieRickli27051062241No139Jean-CharlesRielle27061062395Yes53KathyRiklin25251062355Yes176Jean-FrançoisRime26271062344No237MeinradoRobbiani25261062330No238StéphaneRossini25271062384Yes239ClaudeRuey25281062349Yes173HansRutschmann26441062221No166LouisSchelbert26541062246Yes349SimonSchenk23511062334No29SilviaSchenker26301062351Yes240MarcelScherer25291062317Yes213ErnstSchibli25721062258Yes307UlrichSchlüer24151062312NT15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071062308Yes128RobertoSchmidt27081062376NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301062232Yes177PirminSchwander26311062316Yes129PiusSegmüller27091062199P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331062294No178CarloSommaruga26321062360Yes232PeterSpuhler25351062321Yes233JürgStahl25361062222Yes361LuziStamm23231062292No152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691062273No174HansStöckli26471062304No82DorisStump24211062277No83FranziskaTeuscher24221062373No84AnitaThanei24231062378Yes300GeorgesTheiler24241062233No7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101062366Yes235PierreTriponez25381062336No163AndyTschümperlin26651062225No126Christianvan Singer27271062226Yes180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341062257No181DanielVischer26351062229No130Alecvon Graffenried27111062244Yes131Christophvon Rotz27121062285NT132Erichvon Siebenthal27131062206No133EricVoruz27141062204Yes295ChristianWaber24491062274Yes226HansjörgWalter25411062390Yes227HansruediWandfluh25421062295Yes124ChristianWasserfallen27151062213No448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331062385Yes171RetoWehrli26371062282Yes127ThomasWeibel27281062288No294HansWidmer24461062209Yes172WalterWobmann26381062223No8BrigitWyss27161062367No56UrsulaWyss25441062357Yes168MarkusZemp26561062211No344JosefZisyadis23331062358Yes219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-12T10:46:29ZEntrer en matièreProposition de la minorité Bänziger (ne pas entrer en matière)Proposition de la majorité (entrer en matière)1956Bundesgesetz über den eidgenössischen Finanzhaushalt (Finanzhaushaltgesetz, FHG)Yes117No60NT21ES1P1Yes117No60EH0NT21ES1P156971062543Yes223FabioAbate25651062434Yes153AndreasAebi26701062522Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731062502No50EviAllemann25831062518NT25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711062552Yes30ViolaAmherd26461062586Yes217AdrianAmstutz25841062465No24JosianeAubert26681062596Yes286CasparBaader24541062550Yes65ElviraBader24741062454Yes154DominiqueBaettig26731062455No26MarliesBänziger26721062506Yes164LucBarthassat26491062507NT341J. AlexanderBaumann23691062486Yes206MartinBäumle25851062437No342DidierBerberat23701062498No77MariaBernasconi24361062515Yes282ElmarBigger24761062438Yes207AttilioBignasca25861062592Yes382MaxBinder22701062514NT155PirminBischof26741062553NT383Roland F.Borer22721062523Yes384ToniBortoluzzi22741062503Yes156JacquesBourgeois26751062427No440DanielBrélaz20231062400No48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731062594Yes343ToniBrunner23721062582NT51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871062405Yes208JakobBüchler25881062545Yes283AndréBugnon24771062496No23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661062499Yes162IgnazioCassis26641062561NT210SepCathomas25901062489Yes157TarzisiusCaviezel26771062575Yes272MauriceChevrier24791062463No455MaxChopard-Acklin27341062524NT211AndréDaguet25911062581Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921062546Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931062520Yes222WalterDonzé25641062452Yes276Jean HenriDunant24841062510Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761062462Yes16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781062403NT327EdiEngelberger23821062588NT17YvetteEstermann26791062571No79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481062580Yes267CharlesFavre24871062410Yes125LaurentFavre27251062547NT328HansFehr23831062565No268Hans-JürgFehr24881062532No81JacquelineFehr24551062563No269MarioFehr24891062493NT18DorisFiala26801062456Yes19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811062460Yes202KurtFluri25941062436Yes330PeterFöhn23851062501Yes146OlivierFrançais26821062513Yes203OskarFreysinger25951062479No40ThereseFrösch25961062487Yes165LieniFüglistaller26511062472Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541062526No41ChantalGalladé25971062556Yes20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831062402NT204Jean-RenéGermanier25981062562Yes370UlrichGiezendanner22921062481No21YvonneGilli26841062417No147BastienGirod26851062559Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571062519Yes10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861062442Yes261WalterGlur24941062540No100ChristineGoll22941062430Yes148Jean-PierreGraber26871062451No46MayaGraf25691062407No32EdithGraf-Litscher26521062597Yes149Jean-PierreGrin26881062490ES371AndreasGross22961062468NT150HansGrunder26891062564Yes422Hans RudolfGysin20771062583Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001062466Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961062538No372AndreaHämmerle22981062548Yes158UrsHany26591062470Yes263HansjörgHassler24971062476Yes151AlfredHeer26901062471NT44BeaHeim26011062505Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911062591Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931062415No141AntonioHodgers26921062572Yes45GabiHuber26021062593Yes49RuthHumbel25801062424Yes142ThomasHurter26931062529Yes205MarkusHutter26051062511Yes35JasminHutter-Hutter26041062491Yes194OttoIneichen26061062478Yes256RudolfJoder25021062435No31FrancineJohn-Calame26501062447No143DanielJositsch26941062428Yes257HansKaufmann25031062469No36MargretKiener Nellen26081062412Yes144HansKiller26951062570Yes37MarianneKleiner26091062509NT318JosefKunz23991062449No11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961062464Yes456MartinLandolt27351062453No197JosefLang26111062475No216UeliLeuenberger25791062531Yes198FilippoLeutenegger26121062542NT116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291062528NT199ChristianLevrat26131062589Yes250ArthurLoepfe25111062443No145RicardoLumengo26971062541Yes134ChristianLüscher26981062587Yes251RuediLustenberger25121062497Yes135PeterMalama26991062533Yes38ChristaMarkwalder26141062467No9AdaMarra27261062579Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161062568Yes243WernerMessmer25181062577Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701062414Yes367ChristianMiesch23111062537Yes22IsabelleMoret26601062483NT244ChristophMörgeli25191062484Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001062419No188GeriMüller26151062527Yes189PhilippMüller26161062598Yes159ThomasMüller26611062525NT190WalterMüller26171062418Yes191FelixMüri26181062408Yes246JacquesNeirynck25211062440Yes136YvesNidegger27011062459No175RogerNordmann26481062535Yes192RuediNoser26191062445NT137EricNussbaumer27021062401Yes182GuyParmelin26211062500No247FabioPedrina25221062574Yes313FulvioPelli24091062480Yes183YvanPerrin26221062539NT13SylviePerrinjaquet27031062554Yes184GerhardPfister26231062448Yes236TheophilPfister25231062431No447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321062569No415PaulRechsteiner21431062461No304RudolfRechsteiner24121062420Yes138LukasReimann27041062439No305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131062450Yes187AndréReymond26261062416Yes14NatalieRickli27051062441No139Jean-CharlesRielle27061062595Yes53KathyRiklin25251062555Yes176Jean-FrançoisRime26271062544Yes237MeinradoRobbiani25261062530No238StéphaneRossini25271062584Yes239ClaudeRuey25281062549Yes173HansRutschmann26441062421No166LouisSchelbert26541062446Yes349SimonSchenk23511062534No29SilviaSchenker26301062551Yes240MarcelScherer25291062517Yes213ErnstSchibli25721062458Yes307UlrichSchlüer24151062512NT15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071062508NT128RobertoSchmidt27081062576NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301062432Yes177PirminSchwander26311062516Yes129PiusSegmüller27091062399P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331062494No178CarloSommaruga26321062560Yes232PeterSpuhler25351062521Yes233JürgStahl25361062422Yes361LuziStamm23231062492No152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691062473No174HansStöckli26471062504No82DorisStump24211062477No83FranziskaTeuscher24221062573NT84AnitaThanei24231062578Yes300GeorgesTheiler24241062433No7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101062566Yes235PierreTriponez25381062536No163AndyTschümperlin26651062425No126Christianvan Singer27271062426Yes180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341062457No181DanielVischer26351062429No130Alecvon Graffenried27111062444Yes131Christophvon Rotz27121062485NT132Erichvon Siebenthal27131062406No133EricVoruz27141062404Yes295ChristianWaber24491062474Yes226HansjörgWalter25411062590Yes227HansruediWandfluh25421062495Yes124ChristianWasserfallen27151062413No448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331062585NT171RetoWehrli26371062482Yes127ThomasWeibel27281062488No294HansWidmer24461062409Yes172WalterWobmann26381062423No8BrigitWyss27161062567No56UrsulaWyss25441062557Yes168MarkusZemp26561062411No344JosefZisyadis23331062558Yes219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-12T11:01:28ZArt. 17a, al. 1 et 2Proposition de la minorité Levrat/Kiener NellenProposition de la majorité1957Bundesgesetz über den eidgenössischen Finanzhaushalt (Finanzhaushaltgesetz, FHG)Yes114No57NT27ES1P1Yes114No57EH0NT27ES1P156981062743Yes223FabioAbate25651062634No153AndreasAebi26701062722Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731062702Yes50EviAllemann25831062718NT25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711062752Yes30ViolaAmherd26461062786No217AdrianAmstutz25841062665Yes24JosianeAubert26681062796No286CasparBaader24541062750Yes65ElviraBader24741062654No154DominiqueBaettig26731062655Yes26MarliesBänziger26721062706Yes164LucBarthassat26491062707NT341J. AlexanderBaumann23691062686Yes206MartinBäumle25851062637Yes342DidierBerberat23701062698Yes77MariaBernasconi24361062715No282ElmarBigger24761062638No207AttilioBignasca25861062792No382MaxBinder22701062714NT155PirminBischof26741062753No383Roland F.Borer22721062723No384ToniBortoluzzi22741062703Yes156JacquesBourgeois26751062627Yes440DanielBrélaz20231062600Yes48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731062794No343ToniBrunner23721062782NT51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871062605Yes208JakobBüchler25881062745No283AndréBugnon24771062696Yes23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661062699Yes162IgnazioCassis26641062761Yes210SepCathomas25901062689Yes157TarzisiusCaviezel26771062775Yes272MauriceChevrier24791062663Yes455MaxChopard-Acklin27341062724Yes211AndréDaguet25911062781Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921062746Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931062720Yes222WalterDonzé25641062652No276Jean HenriDunant24841062710Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761062662Yes16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781062603NT327EdiEngelberger23821062788No17YvetteEstermann26791062771Yes79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481062780Yes267CharlesFavre24871062610Yes125LaurentFavre27251062747No328HansFehr23831062765Yes268Hans-JürgFehr24881062732Yes81JacquelineFehr24551062763Yes269MarioFehr24891062693NT18DorisFiala26801062656No19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811062660Yes202KurtFluri25941062636No330PeterFöhn23851062701Yes146OlivierFrançais26821062713No203OskarFreysinger25951062679Yes40ThereseFrösch25961062687No165LieniFüglistaller26511062672Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541062726Yes41ChantalGalladé25971062756No20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831062602NT204Jean-RenéGermanier25981062762No370UlrichGiezendanner22921062681Yes21YvonneGilli26841062617Yes147BastienGirod26851062759Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571062719No10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861062642No261WalterGlur24941062740Yes100ChristineGoll22941062630No148Jean-PierreGraber26871062651Yes46MayaGraf25691062607Yes32EdithGraf-Litscher26521062797No149Jean-PierreGrin26881062690ES371AndreasGross22961062668NT150HansGrunder26891062764Yes422Hans RudolfGysin20771062783Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001062666Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961062738Yes372AndreaHämmerle22981062748NT158UrsHany26591062670Yes263HansjörgHassler24971062676No151AlfredHeer26901062671Yes44BeaHeim26011062705Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911062791Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931062615Yes141AntonioHodgers26921062772Yes45GabiHuber26021062793Yes49RuthHumbel25801062624No142ThomasHurter26931062729Yes205MarkusHutter26051062711No35JasminHutter-Hutter26041062691Yes194OttoIneichen26061062678No256RudolfJoder25021062635Yes31FrancineJohn-Calame26501062647Yes143DanielJositsch26941062628No257HansKaufmann25031062669Yes36MargretKiener Nellen26081062612No144HansKiller26951062770Yes37MarianneKleiner26091062709No318JosefKunz23991062649Yes11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961062664Yes456MartinLandolt27351062653Yes197JosefLang26111062675Yes216UeliLeuenberger25791062731Yes198FilippoLeutenegger26121062742NT116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291062728Yes199ChristianLevrat26131062789Yes250ArthurLoepfe25111062643Yes145RicardoLumengo26971062741Yes134ChristianLüscher26981062787Yes251RuediLustenberger25121062697Yes135PeterMalama26991062733Yes38ChristaMarkwalder26141062667Yes9AdaMarra27261062779Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161062768Yes243WernerMessmer25181062777Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701062614No367ChristianMiesch23111062737NT22IsabelleMoret26601062683NT244ChristophMörgeli25191062684Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001062619Yes188GeriMüller26151062727Yes189PhilippMüller26161062798Yes159ThomasMüller26611062725Yes190WalterMüller26171062618No191FelixMüri26181062608Yes246JacquesNeirynck25211062640NT136YvesNidegger27011062659Yes175RogerNordmann26481062735Yes192RuediNoser26191062645NT137EricNussbaumer27021062601No182GuyParmelin26211062700Yes247FabioPedrina25221062774Yes313FulvioPelli24091062680No183YvanPerrin26221062739NT13SylviePerrinjaquet27031062754Yes184GerhardPfister26231062648No236TheophilPfister25231062631Yes447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321062769Yes415PaulRechsteiner21431062661Yes304RudolfRechsteiner24121062620No138LukasReimann27041062639Yes305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131062650No187AndréReymond26261062616No14NatalieRickli27051062641Yes139Jean-CharlesRielle27061062795Yes53KathyRiklin25251062755No176Jean-FrançoisRime26271062744Yes237MeinradoRobbiani25261062730Yes238StéphaneRossini25271062784Yes239ClaudeRuey25281062749No173HansRutschmann26441062621Yes166LouisSchelbert26541062646No349SimonSchenk23511062734Yes29SilviaSchenker26301062751No240MarcelScherer25291062717No213ErnstSchibli25721062658No307UlrichSchlüer24151062712Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071062708NT128RobertoSchmidt27081062776NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301062632No177PirminSchwander26311062716Yes129PiusSegmüller27091062599P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331062694Yes178CarloSommaruga26321062760No232PeterSpuhler25351062721No233JürgStahl25361062622No361LuziStamm23231062692Yes152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691062673NT174HansStöckli26471062704Yes82DorisStump24211062677Yes83FranziskaTeuscher24221062773NT84AnitaThanei24231062778Yes300GeorgesTheiler24241062633Yes7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101062766Yes235PierreTriponez25381062736Yes163AndyTschümperlin26651062625Yes126Christianvan Singer27271062626No180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341062657Yes181DanielVischer26351062629Yes130Alecvon Graffenried27111062644No131Christophvon Rotz27121062685NT132Erichvon Siebenthal27131062606Yes133EricVoruz27141062604NT295ChristianWaber24491062674No226HansjörgWalter25411062790No227HansruediWandfluh25421062695Yes124ChristianWasserfallen27151062613Yes448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331062785NT171RetoWehrli26371062682Yes127ThomasWeibel27281062688Yes294HansWidmer24461062609No172WalterWobmann26381062623Yes8BrigitWyss27161062767Yes56UrsulaWyss25441062757Yes168MarkusZemp26561062611Yes344JosefZisyadis23331062758No219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-12T11:21:04ZArt. 17b, al. 1Proposition de la minorité I (Füglistaller)Proposition de la majorité1958Bundesgesetz über den eidgenössischen Finanzhaushalt (Finanzhaushaltgesetz, FHG)Yes121No55NT22ES1P1Yes121No55EH0NT22ES1P156991062943Yes223FabioAbate25651062834Yes153AndreasAebi26701062922Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731062902No50EviAllemann25831062918NT25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711062952Yes30ViolaAmherd26461062986Yes217AdrianAmstutz25841062865No24JosianeAubert26681062996Yes286CasparBaader24541062950Yes65ElviraBader24741062854Yes154DominiqueBaettig26731062855No26MarliesBänziger26721062906Yes164LucBarthassat26491062907NT341J. AlexanderBaumann23691062886Yes206MartinBäumle25851062837No342DidierBerberat23701062898No77MariaBernasconi24361062915Yes282ElmarBigger24761062838Yes207AttilioBignasca25861062992Yes382MaxBinder22701062914NT155PirminBischof26741062953Yes383Roland F.Borer22721062923Yes384ToniBortoluzzi22741062903NT156JacquesBourgeois26751062827No440DanielBrélaz20231062800No48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731062994Yes343ToniBrunner23721062982NT51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871062805Yes208JakobBüchler25881062945Yes283AndréBugnon24771062896No23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661062899Yes162IgnazioCassis26641062961Yes210SepCathomas25901062889Yes157TarzisiusCaviezel26771062975Yes272MauriceChevrier24791062863No455MaxChopard-Acklin27341062924No211AndréDaguet25911062981Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921062946Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931062920Yes222WalterDonzé25641062852Yes276Jean HenriDunant24841062910Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761062862Yes16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781062803NT327EdiEngelberger23821062988Yes17YvetteEstermann26791062971No79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481062980Yes267CharlesFavre24871062810Yes125LaurentFavre27251062947Yes328HansFehr23831062965No268Hans-JürgFehr24881062932No81JacquelineFehr24551062963No269MarioFehr24891062893NT18DorisFiala26801062856Yes19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811062860Yes202KurtFluri25941062836Yes330PeterFöhn23851062901Yes146OlivierFrançais26821062913Yes203OskarFreysinger25951062879No40ThereseFrösch25961062887Yes165LieniFüglistaller26511062872Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541062926No41ChantalGalladé25971062956Yes20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831062802NT204Jean-RenéGermanier25981062962Yes370UlrichGiezendanner22921062881No21YvonneGilli26841062817No147BastienGirod26851062959Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571062919Yes10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861062842Yes261WalterGlur24941062940No100ChristineGoll22941062830Yes148Jean-PierreGraber26871062851No46MayaGraf25691062807No32EdithGraf-Litscher26521062997Yes149Jean-PierreGrin26881062890ES371AndreasGross22961062868NT150HansGrunder26891062964Yes422Hans RudolfGysin20771062983Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001062866Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961062938No372AndreaHämmerle22981062948NT158UrsHany26591062870Yes263HansjörgHassler24971062876Yes151AlfredHeer26901062871No44BeaHeim26011062905Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911062991Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931062815No141AntonioHodgers26921062972Yes45GabiHuber26021062993Yes49RuthHumbel25801062824Yes142ThomasHurter26931062929Yes205MarkusHutter26051062911Yes35JasminHutter-Hutter26041062891Yes194OttoIneichen26061062878Yes256RudolfJoder25021062835No31FrancineJohn-Calame26501062847No143DanielJositsch26941062828Yes257HansKaufmann25031062869No36MargretKiener Nellen26081062812Yes144HansKiller26951062970Yes37MarianneKleiner26091062909Yes318JosefKunz23991062849No11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961062864Yes456MartinLandolt27351062853No197JosefLang26111062875No216UeliLeuenberger25791062931Yes198FilippoLeutenegger26121062942NT116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291062928No199ChristianLevrat26131062989Yes250ArthurLoepfe25111062843No145RicardoLumengo26971062941Yes134ChristianLüscher26981062987Yes251RuediLustenberger25121062897Yes135PeterMalama26991062933Yes38ChristaMarkwalder26141062867No9AdaMarra27261062979Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161062968Yes243WernerMessmer25181062977Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701062814Yes367ChristianMiesch23111062937Yes22IsabelleMoret26601062883NT244ChristophMörgeli25191062884Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001062819No188GeriMüller26151062927Yes189PhilippMüller26161062998Yes159ThomasMüller26611062925Yes190WalterMüller26171062818Yes191FelixMüri26181062808Yes246JacquesNeirynck25211062840NT136YvesNidegger27011062859No175RogerNordmann26481062935Yes192RuediNoser26191062845NT137EricNussbaumer27021062801Yes182GuyParmelin26211062900No247FabioPedrina25221062974Yes313FulvioPelli24091062880Yes183YvanPerrin26221062939NT13SylviePerrinjaquet27031062954NT184GerhardPfister26231062848Yes236TheophilPfister25231062831No447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321062969No415PaulRechsteiner21431062861No304RudolfRechsteiner24121062820Yes138LukasReimann27041062839No305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131062850Yes187AndréReymond26261062816Yes14NatalieRickli27051062841No139Jean-CharlesRielle27061062995Yes53KathyRiklin25251062955Yes176Jean-FrançoisRime26271062944No237MeinradoRobbiani25261062930No238StéphaneRossini25271062984Yes239ClaudeRuey25281062949Yes173HansRutschmann26441062821No166LouisSchelbert26541062846Yes349SimonSchenk23511062934No29SilviaSchenker26301062951Yes240MarcelScherer25291062917Yes213ErnstSchibli25721062858Yes307UlrichSchlüer24151062912Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071062908NT128RobertoSchmidt27081062976NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301062832Yes177PirminSchwander26311062916Yes129PiusSegmüller27091062799P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331062894No178CarloSommaruga26321062960Yes232PeterSpuhler25351062921Yes233JürgStahl25361062822Yes361LuziStamm23231062892No152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691062873NT174HansStöckli26471062904No82DorisStump24211062877No83FranziskaTeuscher24221062973NT84AnitaThanei24231062978Yes300GeorgesTheiler24241062833No7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101062966Yes235PierreTriponez25381062936No163AndyTschümperlin26651062825No126Christianvan Singer27271062826Yes180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341062857No181DanielVischer26351062829No130Alecvon Graffenried27111062844Yes131Christophvon Rotz27121062885NT132Erichvon Siebenthal27131062806No133EricVoruz27141062804Yes295ChristianWaber24491062874Yes226HansjörgWalter25411062990Yes227HansruediWandfluh25421062895Yes124ChristianWasserfallen27151062813No448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331062985NT171RetoWehrli26371062882Yes127ThomasWeibel27281062888No294HansWidmer24461062809Yes172WalterWobmann26381062823No8BrigitWyss27161062967No56UrsulaWyss25441062957Yes168MarkusZemp26561062811No344JosefZisyadis23331062958Yes219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-12T11:21:59ZArt. 17b, al. 1Proposition de la minorité II (Bänziger)Proposition de la majorité1959Bundesgesetz über den eidgenössischen Finanzhaushalt (Finanzhaushaltgesetz, FHG)Yes116No60NT22ES1P1Yes116No60EH0NT22ES1P157001063143Yes223FabioAbate25651063034Yes153AndreasAebi26701063122Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731063102NT50EviAllemann25831063118NT25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711063152Yes30ViolaAmherd26461063186Yes217AdrianAmstutz25841063065No24JosianeAubert26681063196Yes286CasparBaader24541063150Yes65ElviraBader24741063054Yes154DominiqueBaettig26731063055No26MarliesBänziger26721063106Yes164LucBarthassat26491063107NT341J. AlexanderBaumann23691063086Yes206MartinBäumle25851063037No342DidierBerberat23701063098No77MariaBernasconi24361063115Yes282ElmarBigger24761063038Yes207AttilioBignasca25861063192Yes382MaxBinder22701063114NT155PirminBischof26741063153Yes383Roland F.Borer22721063123Yes384ToniBortoluzzi22741063103NT156JacquesBourgeois26751063027No440DanielBrélaz20231063000No48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731063194Yes343ToniBrunner23721063182NT51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871063005Yes208JakobBüchler25881063145Yes283AndréBugnon24771063096No23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661063099Yes162IgnazioCassis26641063161Yes210SepCathomas25901063089Yes157TarzisiusCaviezel26771063175Yes272MauriceChevrier24791063063No455MaxChopard-Acklin27341063124No211AndréDaguet25911063181Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921063146Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931063120Yes222WalterDonzé25641063052Yes276Jean HenriDunant24841063110Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761063062Yes16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781063003NT327EdiEngelberger23821063188Yes17YvetteEstermann26791063171No79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481063180Yes267CharlesFavre24871063010Yes125LaurentFavre27251063147Yes328HansFehr23831063165No268Hans-JürgFehr24881063132No81JacquelineFehr24551063163No269MarioFehr24891063093NT18DorisFiala26801063056Yes19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811063060Yes202KurtFluri25941063036Yes330PeterFöhn23851063101Yes146OlivierFrançais26821063113Yes203OskarFreysinger25951063079No40ThereseFrösch25961063087Yes165LieniFüglistaller26511063072Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541063126No41ChantalGalladé25971063156Yes20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831063002NT204Jean-RenéGermanier25981063162Yes370UlrichGiezendanner22921063081No21YvonneGilli26841063017No147BastienGirod26851063159Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571063119Yes10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861063042Yes261WalterGlur24941063140No100ChristineGoll22941063030Yes148Jean-PierreGraber26871063051No46MayaGraf25691063007No32EdithGraf-Litscher26521063197Yes149Jean-PierreGrin26881063090ES371AndreasGross22961063068NT150HansGrunder26891063164Yes422Hans RudolfGysin20771063183Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001063066Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961063138No372AndreaHämmerle22981063148NT158UrsHany26591063070Yes263HansjörgHassler24971063076Yes151AlfredHeer26901063071No44BeaHeim26011063105Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911063191Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931063015No141AntonioHodgers26921063172Yes45GabiHuber26021063193Yes49RuthHumbel25801063024Yes142ThomasHurter26931063129Yes205MarkusHutter26051063111Yes35JasminHutter-Hutter26041063091Yes194OttoIneichen26061063078Yes256RudolfJoder25021063035No31FrancineJohn-Calame26501063047No143DanielJositsch26941063028Yes257HansKaufmann25031063069No36MargretKiener Nellen26081063012Yes144HansKiller26951063170Yes37MarianneKleiner26091063109Yes318JosefKunz23991063049No11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961063064Yes456MartinLandolt27351063053No197JosefLang26111063075No216UeliLeuenberger25791063131Yes198FilippoLeutenegger26121063142NT116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291063128No199ChristianLevrat26131063189Yes250ArthurLoepfe25111063043No145RicardoLumengo26971063141Yes134ChristianLüscher26981063187Yes251RuediLustenberger25121063097Yes135PeterMalama26991063133Yes38ChristaMarkwalder26141063067No9AdaMarra27261063179Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161063168Yes243WernerMessmer25181063177Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701063014Yes367ChristianMiesch23111063137Yes22IsabelleMoret26601063083NT244ChristophMörgeli25191063084Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001063019No188GeriMüller26151063127Yes189PhilippMüller26161063198Yes159ThomasMüller26611063125Yes190WalterMüller26171063018Yes191FelixMüri26181063008Yes246JacquesNeirynck25211063040NT136YvesNidegger27011063059NT175RogerNordmann26481063135Yes192RuediNoser26191063045NT137EricNussbaumer27021063001Yes182GuyParmelin26211063100No247FabioPedrina25221063174Yes313FulvioPelli24091063080Yes183YvanPerrin26221063139NT13SylviePerrinjaquet27031063154Yes184GerhardPfister26231063048Yes236TheophilPfister25231063031No447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321063169No415PaulRechsteiner21431063061No304RudolfRechsteiner24121063020Yes138LukasReimann27041063039No305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131063050Yes187AndréReymond26261063016Yes14NatalieRickli27051063041No139Jean-CharlesRielle27061063195Yes53KathyRiklin25251063155Yes176Jean-FrançoisRime26271063144No237MeinradoRobbiani25261063130No238StéphaneRossini25271063184Yes239ClaudeRuey25281063149Yes173HansRutschmann26441063021No166LouisSchelbert26541063046Yes349SimonSchenk23511063134No29SilviaSchenker26301063151Yes240MarcelScherer25291063117Yes213ErnstSchibli25721063058Yes307UlrichSchlüer24151063112Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071063108NT128RobertoSchmidt27081063176NT241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301063032Yes177PirminSchwander26311063116Yes129PiusSegmüller27091062999P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331063094No178CarloSommaruga26321063160Yes232PeterSpuhler25351063121Yes233JürgStahl25361063022Yes361LuziStamm23231063092No152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691063073NT174HansStöckli26471063104NT82DorisStump24211063077No83FranziskaTeuscher24221063173NT84AnitaThanei24231063178Yes300GeorgesTheiler24241063033No7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101063166Yes235PierreTriponez25381063136No163AndyTschümperlin26651063025No126Christianvan Singer27271063026Yes180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341063057No181DanielVischer26351063029No130Alecvon Graffenried27111063044Yes131Christophvon Rotz27121063085NT132Erichvon Siebenthal27131063006No133EricVoruz27141063004Yes295ChristianWaber24491063074Yes226HansjörgWalter25411063190Yes227HansruediWandfluh25421063095Yes124ChristianWasserfallen27151063013No448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331063185NT171RetoWehrli26371063082Yes127ThomasWeibel27281063088No294HansWidmer24461063009Yes172WalterWobmann26381063023No8BrigitWyss27161063167No56UrsulaWyss25441063157Yes168MarkusZemp26561063011No344JosefZisyadis23331063158Yes219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-12T11:23:32ZVote sur l'ensemble1960Bundesgesetz über den eidgenössischen Finanzhaushalt (Finanzhaushaltgesetz, FHG)Yes117No57NT24ES1P1Yes117No57EH0NT24ES1P15815false1085344Yes223FabioAbate25651085234Yes153AndreasAebi26701085323Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731085303No50EviAllemann25831085319NT25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711085353Yes30ViolaAmherd26461085388Yes217AdrianAmstutz25841085265No24JosianeAubert26681085398Yes286CasparBaader24541085351Yes65ElviraBader24741085254Yes154DominiqueBaettig26731085255No26MarliesBänziger26721085307Yes164LucBarthassat26491085308Yes341J. AlexanderBaumann23691085287Yes206MartinBäumle25851085237No342DidierBerberat23701085299No77MariaBernasconi24361085316Yes282ElmarBigger24761085238Yes207AttilioBignasca25861085394Yes382MaxBinder22701085315Yes155PirminBischof26741085354Yes383Roland F.Borer22721085324Yes384ToniBortoluzzi22741085304Yes156JacquesBourgeois26751085227No440DanielBrélaz20231085200No48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731085396Yes343ToniBrunner23721085384Yes51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871085205Yes208JakobBüchler25881085346Yes283AndréBugnon24771085297No23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661085300Yes162IgnazioCassis26641085363Yes210SepCathomas25901085290Yes157TarzisiusCaviezel26771085377Yes272MauriceChevrier24791085263No455MaxChopard-Acklin27341085325No211AndréDaguet25911085383Yes200ChristopheDarbellay25921085347Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931085321Yes222WalterDonzé25641085252Yes276Jean HenriDunant24841085311Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761085262Yes16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781085203Yes327EdiEngelberger23821085390Yes17YvetteEstermann26791085373No79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481085382Yes267CharlesFavre24871085210Yes125LaurentFavre27251085348Yes328HansFehr23831085367No268Hans-JürgFehr24881085333No81JacquelineFehr24551085365No269MarioFehr24891085294Yes18DorisFiala26801085256Yes19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811085260Yes202KurtFluri25941085236Yes330PeterFöhn23851085302Yes146OlivierFrançais26821085314Yes203OskarFreysinger25951085279No40ThereseFrösch25961085288Yes165LieniFüglistaller26511085272Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541085327No41ChantalGalladé25971085358Yes20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831085202Yes204Jean-RenéGermanier25981085364Yes370UlrichGiezendanner22921085281No21YvonneGilli26841085217No147BastienGirod26851085361Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571085320Yes10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861085242Yes261WalterGlur24941085341No100ChristineGoll22941085230Yes148Jean-PierreGraber26871085251No46MayaGraf25691085207No32EdithGraf-Litscher26521085282Yes149Jean-PierreGrin26881085291NT371AndreasGross22961085268Yes150HansGrunder26891085366Yes422Hans RudolfGysin20771085385Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001085266Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961085339No372AndreaHämmerle22981085349Yes158UrsHany26591085270Yes263HansjörgHassler24971085276Yes151AlfredHeer26901085271No44BeaHeim26011085306Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911085393Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931085215No141AntonioHodgers26921085374Yes45GabiHuber26021085395Yes49RuthHumbel25801085224Yes142ThomasHurter26931085330Yes205MarkusHutter26051085312Yes35JasminHutter-Hutter26041085292Yes194OttoIneichen26061085278Yes256RudolfJoder25021085235No31FrancineJohn-Calame26501085247No143DanielJositsch26941085228Yes257HansKaufmann25031085269No36MargretKiener Nellen26081085212Yes144HansKiller26951085372Yes37MarianneKleiner26091085310Yes318JosefKunz23991085249No11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961085264Yes456MartinLandolt27351085253No197JosefLang26111085275No216UeliLeuenberger25791085332Yes198FilippoLeutenegger26121085343No116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291085329No199ChristianLevrat26131085391Yes250ArthurLoepfe25111085243No145RicardoLumengo26971085342Yes134ChristianLüscher26981085389Yes251RuediLustenberger25121085298Yes135PeterMalama26991085334Yes38ChristaMarkwalder26141085267No9AdaMarra27261085381Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161085370Yes243WernerMessmer25181085379Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701085214Yes367ChristianMiesch23111085338Yes22IsabelleMoret26601085284Yes244ChristophMörgeli25191085285Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001085219No188GeriMüller26151085328Yes189PhilippMüller26161085357Yes159ThomasMüller26611085326Yes190WalterMüller26171085218Yes191FelixMüri26181085208NT246JacquesNeirynck25211085240NT136YvesNidegger27011085259No175RogerNordmann26481085336NT192RuediNoser26191085245No137EricNussbaumer27021085201Yes182GuyParmelin26211085301No247FabioPedrina25221085376Yes313FulvioPelli24091085280Yes183YvanPerrin26221085340Yes13SylviePerrinjaquet27031085355Yes184GerhardPfister26231085248Yes236TheophilPfister25231085231No447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321085371No415PaulRechsteiner21431085261No304RudolfRechsteiner24121085220Yes138LukasReimann27041085239No305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131085250Yes187AndréReymond26261085216Yes14NatalieRickli27051085241NT139Jean-CharlesRielle27061085397Yes53KathyRiklin25251085356Yes176Jean-FrançoisRime26271085345EH237MeinradoRobbiani25261085331No238StéphaneRossini25271085386Yes239ClaudeRuey25281085350Yes173HansRutschmann26441085221No166LouisSchelbert26541085246Yes349SimonSchenk23511085335No29SilviaSchenker26301085352Yes240MarcelScherer25291085318Yes213ErnstSchibli25721085258Yes307UlrichSchlüer24151085313Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071085309Yes128RobertoSchmidt27081085378Yes241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301085232Yes177PirminSchwander26311085317Yes129PiusSegmüller27091085199P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331085295No178CarloSommaruga26321085362Yes232PeterSpuhler25351085322Yes233JürgStahl25361085222Yes361LuziStamm23231085293No152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691085273No174HansStöckli26471085305No82DorisStump24211085277No83FranziskaTeuscher24221085375No84AnitaThanei24231085380NT300GeorgesTheiler24241085233No7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101085368Yes235PierreTriponez25381085337No163AndyTschümperlin26651085225No126Christianvan Singer27271085226Yes180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341085257No181DanielVischer26351085229EH130Alecvon Graffenried27111085244Yes131Christophvon Rotz27121085286Yes132Erichvon Siebenthal27131085206No133EricVoruz27141085204Yes295ChristianWaber24491085274Yes226HansjörgWalter25411085392Yes227HansruediWandfluh25421085296Yes124ChristianWasserfallen27151085213No448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331085387Yes171RetoWehrli26371085283Yes127ThomasWeibel27281085289No294HansWidmer24461085209Yes172WalterWobmann26381085223No8BrigitWyss27161085369No56UrsulaWyss25441085359Yes168MarkusZemp26561085211No344JosefZisyadis23331085360Yes219BrunoZuppiger25472009-03-20T10:48:18ZVote final2075Bundesgesetz über den eidgenössischen Finanzhaushalt (Finanzhaushaltgesetz, FHG)Yes129No61EH2NT7P1Yes129No61EH2NT7ES0P1