200831312026-04-19T03:05:29Z61491142944Yes223FabioAbate25651142834Yes153AndreasAebi26701142923Yes281RuediAeschbacher24731142903No50EviAllemann25831142919NT25KathrinAmacker-Amann26711142953Yes30ViolaAmherd26461142988Yes217AdrianAmstutz25841142865No24JosianeAubert26681142998Yes286CasparBaader24541142951Yes65ElviraBader24741142854Yes154DominiqueBaettig26731142855No26MarliesBänziger26721142907Yes164LucBarthassat26491142908Yes341J. AlexanderBaumann23691142887Yes206MartinBäumle25851142837No342DidierBerberat23701142899No77MariaBernasconi24361142916Yes282ElmarBigger24761142838NT207AttilioBignasca25861142994Yes382MaxBinder22701142915Yes155PirminBischof26741142954Yes383Roland F.Borer22721142924Yes384ToniBortoluzzi22741142904Yes156JacquesBourgeois26751142827No440DanielBrélaz20231142800No48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731142996Yes343ToniBrunner23721142984Yes51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871142805Yes208JakobBüchler25881142946Yes283AndréBugnon24771142897No23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661142900Yes162IgnazioCassis26641142963Yes210SepCathomas25901142890Yes157TarzisiusCaviezel26771142977Yes272MauriceChevrier24791142863No455MaxChopard-Acklin27341142925No211AndréDaguet25911142983NT200ChristopheDarbellay25921142947Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931142921EH222WalterDonzé25641142852Yes276Jean HenriDunant24841142911Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761142862Yes16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781142803Yes327EdiEngelberger23821142990Yes17YvetteEstermann26791142973No79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481142982Yes267CharlesFavre24871142810Yes125LaurentFavre27251142948Yes328HansFehr23831142967No268Hans-JürgFehr24881142933No81JacquelineFehr24551142965No269MarioFehr24891142894Yes18DorisFiala26801142856Yes19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811142860Yes202KurtFluri25941142836Yes330PeterFöhn23851142902Yes146OlivierFrançais26821142914Yes203OskarFreysinger25951142879No40ThereseFrösch25961142888Yes165LieniFüglistaller26511142872Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541142927No41ChantalGalladé25971142958Yes20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831142802Yes204Jean-RenéGermanier25981142964Yes370UlrichGiezendanner22921142881No21YvonneGilli26841142817No147BastienGirod26851142961Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571142920Yes10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861142842Yes261WalterGlur24941142941No100ChristineGoll22941142830Yes148Jean-PierreGraber26871142851No46MayaGraf25691142807No32EdithGraf-Litscher26521142882Yes149Jean-PierreGrin26881142891NT371AndreasGross22961142868Yes150HansGrunder26891142966NT422Hans RudolfGysin20771142985Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001142866Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961142939No372AndreaHämmerle22981142949Yes158UrsHany26591142870Yes263HansjörgHassler24971142876Yes151AlfredHeer26901142871No44BeaHeim26011142906Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911142993Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931142815No141AntonioHodgers26921142974Yes45GabiHuber26021142995Yes49RuthHumbel25801142824Yes142ThomasHurter26931142930Yes205MarkusHutter26051142912Yes35JasminHutter-Hutter26041142892Yes194OttoIneichen26061142878Yes256RudolfJoder25021142835No31FrancineJohn-Calame26501142847No143DanielJositsch26941142828NT257HansKaufmann25031142869No36MargretKiener Nellen26081142812Yes144HansKiller26951142972Yes37MarianneKleiner26091142910Yes318JosefKunz23991142849No11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961142864Yes456MartinLandolt27351142853No197JosefLang26111142875No216UeliLeuenberger25791142932Yes198FilippoLeutenegger26121142943No116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291142929No199ChristianLevrat26131142991Yes250ArthurLoepfe25111142843NT145RicardoLumengo26971142942Yes134ChristianLüscher26981142989Yes251RuediLustenberger25121142898Yes135PeterMalama26991142934Yes38ChristaMarkwalder26141142867No9AdaMarra27261142981Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161142970NT243WernerMessmer25181142979Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701142814Yes367ChristianMiesch23111142938Yes22IsabelleMoret26601142884Yes244ChristophMörgeli25191142885Yes12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001142819No188GeriMüller26151142928Yes189PhilippMüller26161142957Yes159ThomasMüller26611142926Yes190WalterMüller26171142818Yes191FelixMüri26181142808Yes246JacquesNeirynck25211142840Yes136YvesNidegger27011142859No175RogerNordmann26481142936NT192RuediNoser26191142845No137EricNussbaumer27021142801Yes182GuyParmelin26211142901No247FabioPedrina25221142976Yes313FulvioPelli24091142880Yes183YvanPerrin26221142940Yes13SylviePerrinjaquet27031142955Yes184GerhardPfister26231142848Yes236TheophilPfister25231142831No447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321142971No415PaulRechsteiner21431142861No304RudolfRechsteiner24121142820Yes138LukasReimann27041142839No305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131142850Yes187AndréReymond26261142816Yes14NatalieRickli27051142841No139Jean-CharlesRielle27061142997Yes53KathyRiklin25251142956Yes176Jean-FrançoisRime26271142945Yes237MeinradoRobbiani25261142931No238StéphaneRossini25271142986Yes239ClaudeRuey25281142950Yes173HansRutschmann26441142821No166LouisSchelbert26541142846Yes349SimonSchenk23511142935No29SilviaSchenker26301142952Yes240MarcelScherer25291142918Yes213ErnstSchibli25721142858Yes307UlrichSchlüer24151142913Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071142909Yes128RobertoSchmidt27081142978Yes241Johann N.Schneider-Ammann25301142832Yes177PirminSchwander26311142917Yes129PiusSegmüller27091142799P54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331142895No178CarloSommaruga26321142962NT232PeterSpuhler25351142922Yes233JürgStahl25361142822Yes361LuziStamm23231142893No152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691142873No174HansStöckli26471142905No82DorisStump24211142877No83FranziskaTeuscher24221142975No84AnitaThanei24231142980Yes300GeorgesTheiler24241142833No7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101142968Yes235PierreTriponez25381142937No163AndyTschümperlin26651142825No126Christianvan Singer27271142826Yes180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341142857No181DanielVischer26351142829No130Alecvon Graffenried27111142844Yes131Christophvon Rotz27121142886Yes132Erichvon Siebenthal27131142806No133EricVoruz27141142804Yes295ChristianWaber24491142874Yes226HansjörgWalter25411142992Yes227HansruediWandfluh25421142896Yes124ChristianWasserfallen27151142813No448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331142987Yes171RetoWehrli26371142883Yes127ThomasWeibel27281142889NT294HansWidmer24461142809Yes172WalterWobmann26381142823No8BrigitWyss27161142969NT56UrsulaWyss25441142959Yes168MarkusZemp26561142811No344JosefZisyadis23331142960NT219BrunoZuppiger25472009-06-03T11:09:30ZRejeter la motionApprouver la motion2409Yes125No60EH1NT13P1Yes125No60EH1NT13ES0P18565false1546343Yes223FabioAbate25651546234Yes153AndreasAebi26701546302No50EviAllemann25831546352Yes30ViolaAmherd26461546387NT217AdrianAmstutz25841546264No24JosianeAubert26681546396Yes286CasparBaader24541546350Yes65ElviraBader24741546253Yes154DominiqueBaettig26731546254NT26MarliesBänziger26721546306Yes164LucBarthassat26491546307NT341J. AlexanderBaumann23691546286EH206MartinBäumle25851546298No77MariaBernasconi24361546315Yes282ElmarBigger24761546392Yes382MaxBinder22701546244No464PriscaBirrer-Heimo27431546314Yes155PirminBischof26741546353NT383Roland F.Borer22721546323Yes384ToniBortoluzzi22741546303Yes156JacquesBourgeois26751546227NT440DanielBrélaz20231546273Yes459AndreasBrönnimann27371546336No48PascaleBruderer Wyss25731546394NT343ToniBrunner23721546383Yes51MartineBrunschwig Graf25871546311Yes462Roland RinoBüchel27401546205Yes208JakobBüchler25881546345Yes283AndréBugnon24771546296No23MarinaCarobbio Guscetti26661546299Yes162IgnazioCassis26641546362Yes210SepCathomas25901546289Yes157TarzisiusCaviezel26771546262No455MaxChopard-Acklin27341546324No211AndréDaguet25911546382NT200ChristopheDarbellay25921546346Yes201Dominiquede Buman25931546310Yes27EstherEgger-Wyss26761546261NT16CorinaEichenberger-Walther26781546203ES327EdiEngelberger23821546389Yes17YvetteEstermann26791546372NT79HildegardFässler-Osterwalder24481546381Yes267CharlesFavre24871546210Yes125LaurentFavre27251546347Yes328HansFehr23831546366NT268Hans-JürgFehr24881546332No81JacquelineFehr24551546364NT269MarioFehr24891546293ES18DorisFiala26801546329NT469PeterFlück27491546255Yes19SylviaFlückiger-Bäni26811546259Yes202KurtFluri25941546236Yes330PeterFöhn23851546301NT146OlivierFrançais26821546251Yes470SebastianFrehner27501546313NT203OskarFreysinger25951546278No40ThereseFrösch25961546287Yes165LieniFüglistaller26511546271Yes94Brigitta M.Gadient23541546326NT41ChantalGalladé25971546357Yes20Andrea MartinaGeissbühler26831546199P204Jean-RenéGermanier25981546363NT370UlrichGiezendanner22921546280NT21YvonneGilli26841546217No147BastienGirod26851546360Yes33IdaGlanzmann-Hunkeler26571546319Yes10AliceGlauser-Zufferey26861546241Yes261WalterGlur24941546238Yes461NormanGobbi27391546340No100ChristineGoll22941546230Yes148Jean-PierreGraber26871546202No46MayaGraf25691546207ES32EdithGraf-Litscher26521546281Yes149Jean-PierreGrin26881546290NT371AndreasGross22961546267Yes150HansGrunder26891546365Yes422Hans RudolfGysin20771546384Yes43BrigitteHäberli-Koller26001546265Yes58UrsulaHaller Vannini24961546338No372AndreaHämmerle22981546348Yes158UrsHany26591546269Yes263HansjörgHassler24971546275NT151AlfredHeer26901546270No44BeaHeim26011546305Yes140HuguesHiltpold26911546398Yes325NorbertHochreutener23931546215No141AntonioHodgers26921546373Yes45GabiHuber26021546393Yes49RuthHumbel25801546224NT142ThomasHurter26931546377NT205MarkusHutter26051546291NT194OttoIneichen26061546322Yes465MajaIngold27441546242No466BeatJans27451546277Yes256RudolfJoder25021546235No31FrancineJohn-Calame26501546288No143DanielJositsch26941546228Yes257HansKaufmann25031546268No36MargretKiener Nellen26081546212Yes144HansKiller26951546371NT37MarianneKleiner26091546309Yes318JosefKunz23991546250No11AnitaLachenmeier-Thüring26961546263Yes456MartinLandolt27351546252No197JosefLang26111546274No216UeliLeuenberger25791546331Yes198FilippoLeutenegger26121546342NT116SusanneLeutenegger Oberholzer21291546328NT199ChristianLevrat26131546390Yes250ArthurLoepfe25111546248No145RicardoLumengo26971546341Yes134ChristianLüscher26981546388Yes251RuediLustenberger25121546239No460Jacques-AndréMaire27381546297NT135PeterMalama26991546333Yes38ChristaMarkwalder26141546266NT9AdaMarra27261546380Yes62LucreziaMeier-Schatz25161546369NT243WernerMessmer25181546378Yes64ThérèseMeyer-Kaelin24701546214Yes367ChristianMiesch23111546337Yes22IsabelleMoret26601546283Yes244ChristophMörgeli25191546284EH12Tiana AngelinaMoser27001546219NT188GeriMüller26151546327Yes189PhilippMüller26161546356Yes159ThomasMüller26611546325Yes190WalterMüller26171546218Yes191FelixMüri26181546208NT246JacquesNeirynck25211546397NT136YvesNidegger27011546258No175RogerNordmann26481546335Yes192RuediNoser26191546260No137EricNussbaumer27021546201Yes182GuyParmelin26211546300No247FabioPedrina25221546375Yes313FulvioPelli24091546279Yes183YvanPerrin26221546339Yes13SylviePerrinjaquet27031546354Yes184GerhardPfister26231546247Yes236TheophilPfister25231546231NT447KatharinaPrelicz-Huber27321546370No415PaulRechsteiner21431546220Yes138LukasReimann27041546237NT305Jean-ClaudeRennwald24131546249Yes187AndréReymond26261546216Yes14NatalieRickli27051546240No139Jean-CharlesRielle27061546395Yes53KathyRiklin25251546355NT176Jean-FrançoisRime26271546344Yes237MeinradoRobbiani25261546330No238StéphaneRossini25271546316Yes463Paul-AndréRoux27421546385Yes239ClaudeRuey25281546349Yes173HansRutschmann26441546221No166LouisSchelbert26541546245Yes349SimonSchenk23511546334No29SilviaSchenker26301546351Yes240MarcelScherer25291546317Yes213ErnstSchibli25721546257Yes307UlrichSchlüer24151546312Yes15BarbaraSchmid-Federer27071546308Yes128RobertoSchmidt27081546318Yes468ElisabethSchneider-Schneiter27481546232Yes177PirminSchwander26311546204Yes129PiusSegmüller27091546376Yes54ChiaraSimoneschi-Cortesi25331546294No178CarloSommaruga26321546361NT232PeterSpuhler25351546321NT233JürgStahl25361546222Yes361LuziStamm23231546292No152Jean-FrançoisSteiert26691546272NT174HansStöckli26471546320Yes467MarianneStreiff-Feller27471546304No82DorisStump24211546276No83FranziskaTeuscher24221546374No84AnitaThanei24231546379NT300GeorgesTheiler24241546233No7AdèleThorens Goumaz27101546367NT235PierreTriponez25381546246No163AndyTschümperlin26651546225No126Christianvan Singer27271546226Yes180Pierre-FrançoisVeillon26341546256No181DanielVischer26351546229No130Alecvon Graffenried27111546243Yes131Christophvon Rotz27121546285Yes132Erichvon Siebenthal27131546206No133EricVoruz27141546200NT226HansjörgWalter25411546391NT227HansruediWandfluh25421546295Yes124ChristianWasserfallen27151546213No448Marie-ThérèseWeber-Gobet27331546386NT171RetoWehrli26371546282EH127ThomasWeibel27281546209Yes172WalterWobmann26381546223NT8BrigitWyss27161546368NT56UrsulaWyss25441546358Yes168MarkusZemp26561546211NT344JosefZisyadis23331546359Yes219BrunoZuppiger25472010-12-08T13:00:05ZProposition de la minorité Jositsch (rejeter la motion dans sa version modifiée)Proposition de la majorité (adopter la motion dans sa version modifiée)4825Yes103No45EH3NT45ES3P1Yes103No45EH3NT45ES3P1